匷å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠã¯ãèšåºã®æ çµã¿ãè¶ ããåé¡ãæèµ·ããŠãããããªãã¡ãå»ççç¥èããããªãæã«ãä»è ã®èº«äœãæå¿ããããŠèªç±ã«å¯Ÿããæš©åãžãšæ£åœã«è»¢åãåŸãã®ããšããåé¡ã§ããã
å»åŠã«ã¯ãçãããšã®å°é£ãªç§åŠçæš©åšããããå»åž«ã¯æ£è æ¬äººãããç確ã«èšºæãäžããããæ£ç¢ºã«ãªã¹ã¯ãè©äŸ¡ããèŠçãåããããçåœãæã£ãããåŸãä»å ¥ãæšå¥šããããšãã§ããããããããã®æè¡çåªäœæ§ãããä»è ã«ä»£ãã£ãŠæ±ºå®ãäžãæš©å©ãèªåçã«å°ãåºãããããã§ã¯ãªãã
ããã®æ²»çã¯ããããããªãã«ãšã£ãŠæçã§ãããããšæèšããããšãšãããã®æ²»çã¯ããããããªãã«ãšã£ãŠæçã§ããããããã£ãŠãããªããæåŠãããšããŠãç§ãã¡ã¯ããã匷å¶ã§ããŸãããšæèšããããšã®éã«ã¯ãæ ¹æ¬çãªéããååšãããåè ã®åœé¡ã¯å»ççç¥èã«å±ããŠãããåŸè ã®åœé¡ã¯æš©åã®åé¡ã«å±ããŠããã
é©çšç¯å²ã«é¢ããæ³šèšïŒ æ¬åæã¯ãå»åŠã粟ç¥çŸæ£ã®ååšããããã¯ç¹å®ã®ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠçæ²»çã®æå¹æ§ãåŠå®ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããŸããå»åž«ãå»çæ©é¢ããããã¯å®¶æã«æªæãåž°ãããã®ã§ããªããæ¬çš¿ãæ€èšããã®ã¯ãããä»å ¥ãæåŠããŠãã人ç©ã®æå¿ãå¶åºŠã代æ¿ããããšããéã«ããããªãæ£åœåãèŠæ±ãããã®ããšããç¹ã§ããã
åé¡ãæç¢ºã«åãåããããã«ãæã奜éœåãªã·ããªãªãæ³å®ããããšãã蚱容ããããããããªããããªãã¡ã蚺æãæ£ç¢ºã§ãããå°éå®¶ãæèœã§ãããæ²»çãå¥å¹ããåççãªèŠèŸŒã¿ããããä»å ¥ãæãè ãã¡ãæ£è ã®å©çã®ããã«è¡åããŠãããšå¿ãã確信ããŠãããšããç¶æ³ã§ããã
ããã§ããªããæ±ºå®çãªåããæ®ãããä»ã®æäººã«ãšã£ãŠäœãæçãšãªãåŸããã«ã€ããŠã®ç¥èãããã®äººç©ã®æå¿ã代æ¿ããæš©å©ãžãšå€ãããã®ã¯äœãªã®ãã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ å°éç¥èã¯æ±ºå®ã®æéãšãªãåŸãããããèªäœã§ãã®äººç©ã«å¯Ÿããç®¡èœæš©ãä»äžããããã§ã¯ãªããæç€ºçãªæçµ¶ã«åããŠèªç±ãå¶éãããã身äœã«ä»å ¥ãããããããšããéã«ã¯ãç¬ç«ããããšããã峿 Œãªæ£åœåãå¿ èŠãšãããã
ãã®åé¡ã¯ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠããå§ãŸãããã§ã¯ãªããå人ã®èªåŸæ§ããã¿ãŒããªãºã ãå»çåããããŠå»åŠã®å¶åºŠçæ¡å€§ãããããããåºç¯ãªè°è«ã®äžéšã§ããããããã蚺æã倿èœåã®è©äŸ¡ãå±éºæ§ã®äºæž¬ãèªç±ã®å¥å¥ªããããŠéèªçºçæ²»çãäžç¹ã«åæãåŸã匷å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠã«ãããŠãããã¯ç¹æã®æ·±å»ãã«éããã
ãªããã®æš©åã®éäžãåé¡ãšãªãã®ããçè§£ããããã«ã¯ãåç¹ããå§ããã®ãé©åã§ãããããªãã¡ãå人ã¯èªåèªèº«ã«å¯ŸããŠã©ã®ãããªæš©åšãæããŠããã®ãããããŠããã代æ¿ããããšããè ã¯äœã蚌æããªããã°ãªããªãã®ããšããç¹ã§ããã
1. 身äœç䞻暩ã匷å¶ããããŠãã¿ãŒããªãºã
åºçºç¹ã¯åçŽã§ãããåå人ããšããã匷åãªæš©åšãæããé åãååšãããã®é åã«ã¯èªåèªèº«ã®èº«äœãå«ãŸããŠããã
John Locke ã¯ãèªå·±ã®èº«äœã»äººæ Œã«å¯Ÿããæææš©ãšããæŠå¿µãéããŠããã®ææ³ã®å€å žçãªå é§äŸã®ã²ãšã€ãå®åŒåãããåŸã«ãããŸããŸãªèªç±äž»çŸ©ïŒãªãã©ã«ïŒããã³ãªãã¿ãªã¢ã³ã®æœ®æµããèªå·±æææš©ïŒself-ownershipïŒãå人ã®èªåŸæ§ã身äœç䞻暩ãšãã£ãæŠå¿µã®äžã§ãããå±éããããšã«ãªãã
身äœã«å¯Ÿããæææš©çè«ãæåéãã«åãå ¥ããªããšãããã®åºæ¬çãªçŽèгãåãå ¥ããããšã¯ã§ãããããªãã¡ã人éã¯èªåèªèº«ã«å¯ŸããŠäœããªãããããæ±ºå®ããããšããã匷åãªæš©å©äž»åŒµãæãããšããããšã§ããããã®ææ³ã¯ãå人ã®äž»æš©ã®æŠå¿µãžãšçŽæ¥ã€ãªãã£ãŠããã人éã¯åœå®¶ã倿°æŽŸãæ©é¢ããããã¯ç¬¬äžè ã®ææç©ã§ã¯ãªãã
John Stuart Mill ã¯ãã®è°è«ãããã«æšãé²ããããèªç±è«ãïŒOn LibertyïŒã«ãããŠåœŒã¯ãããå人ã®èäœçãŸãã¯é埳çãªå©çããèªäœã¯ããã®äººç©ã«å¯ŸããŠåŒ·å¶åãè¡äœ¿ããããã®ååãªçç±ã«ã¯ãªããªããšäž»åŒµããèªå·±ã®èº«äœãšç²Ÿç¥ã«å¯Ÿããå人ã®äž»æš©ãæç€ºçã«å®åŒåããã圌ã®ååã¯åå šãªèœåãåããæäººã察象ãšããŠãããä»è ãžã®å±å®³ãšãäž»ãšããŠãã®å人èªèº«ã«é¢ããè¡çºãšãåºå¥ããŠããïŒMill, 1859ïŒã
ããããæ¬è³ªçãªåºå¥ã®åºç€ãšãªã£ãŠããã
èªèçæš©åšã¯ãäººæ Œçæš©åšãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
è «çå ç§å»ã¯ãç§ãããããã«ã€ããŠçç¥ããŠãããããããªããå€ç§å»ã¯ãç§ãããæè¡ã«é¢ãã確çãé©åã«è©äŸ¡ã§ãããããããªãã粟ç¥ç§å»ã¯ãç§ãæããªã粟ç¥ç çåŠã«é¢ããç¥èãæããŠãããããããªãã
ãããã¯äžåè°è«ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ã§ã¯ãªãã
ãããªãæ£åœåãå¿ èŠãšããã®ã¯ã以äžããã®é£èºã§ããã
ãç§ã¯ãã®ä»¶ã«ã€ããŠããªããããç¥èãããã
ããã
ãã ããç§ã¯ããªãã«ä»£ãã£ãŠæ±ºå®ã§ããããžã
ãã®é£èºã¯æ¿æ²»çãã€é埳çãªãã®ã§ãããç§åŠçãªãã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
ãŸãã説åŸãšåŒ·å¶ãåºå¥ããããšãæ±ãããããæ å ±æäŸãå©èšãè«èšŒããããŠçŽåŸãããããšãã詊ã¿ã¯ãèªåŸæ§ãšäž¡ç«ãã圱é¿åã®åœ¢æ ã§ããã匷å¶ã¯å¥ã®è«çãå°å ¥ãããããªãã¡ã決å®ãå®åãè è¿«ããããã¯éžæã®èªç±ãå®è³ªçã«çããã»ã©åŒ·åã«ä»è ã«ãã£ãŠå¶åŸ¡ãããçµæã«ãã£ãŠæ¡ä»¶ã¥ããããã®ã§ããã
ããããå°é£ãããããå§è¿«ã匷å¶ãæ§æããããã§ã¯ãªãããŸãã«ããããã«ããã®èªãç¡å·®å¥ã«çšããªãããšãæãŸããããããã匷å¶ãç®ã«èŠããç©ççæŽåã«éå®ããŠç®å°åãã¹ãã§ããªããå¶è£ã«è£æã¡ãããè è¿«ã¯ãæææ±ºå®ã®æ§é ãæ ¹æ¬ããå€å®¹ããåŸãã
Libertatis Venezuela ã§ã¯ãã§ã«ããåœå®¶ã®åŒ·å¶ïŒããã¯ãããªããã®ã§ããããªãèªç±äž»çŸ©ã«ãšã£ãŠã®æžå¿µãšãªãã®ããã«ãããŠãã®åé¡ãè«ããŠãããåœå®¶ã¯åã«æšå¥šããã«ãšã©ãŸããªããèŠç¯ãå¶è£ãè£å€æããããŠèŠå¯æš©åã»å ¬æš©åãçšããŠçŸ©åã課ãããšãã§ããããã®ããšã¯åœå®¶ã®ãã¹ãŠã®åŒ·å¶ãäžåœã«ããããã§ã¯ãªããããã®æ ¹æ ãæ¯äŸæ§ãéçããããŠçµ±å¶ã®ã¡ã«ããºã ã«ã€ããŠåãããšãå¿ ç¶çã«èŠæ±ããã
å»çã«ãããŠãã®åé¡ããšãããç¹çŽ°ãªæ§çžãåããã®ã¯ã匷å¶ãåŠçœ°ãšããŠã§ã¯ãªããåè¡ïŒåçã®æäŸïŒãšããŠæ£åœåãããããšãå€ãããã§ããã
ããã«ãã¿ãŒããªãºã ãç»å Žããã
ãã¿ãŒããªãºã ãšã¯ãæŠããŠãããå人ã®èªç±ãèªåŸæ§ã«å¹²æžãããã®å¹²æžããã®äººç©èªèº«ã«ãããããšãããå©çã«ãã£ãŠãããæ£åœåããããšãæãïŒããŠã©ãŒãã³ãã¹ã¿ã³ãã©ãŒãå²åŠçŸç§äºå ž). ãã®è°è«ã«ãããŠã¯ã決å®ãçã«èªåŸçãªãã®ã§ãããã確èªããããšãç®çãšããä»å ¥ãšãæš©åšåŽã誀ãã§ãããšèŠãªããããã«ãçè§£ããèªçºçã«ãªãããæ±ºå®ã代æ¿ããŠããŸãä»å ¥ãšãåºå¥ãããã
åŸè ã®åœ¢æ ããããæãåé¡å«ã¿ã§ããã
ãªããªããããä»å ¥ãæçã§ãããªãããäŸç¶ãšããŠåŒ·å¶çã§ããç¶ããããšãããåŸãããã§ããã
åè¡ãšåŒ·å¶ã®æ£åœæ§ã¯ãåäžã®ãã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
2. ééãæš©å©ãšãªã¹ã¯ã®å°å³
èªåŸæ§ã¯ãä»è ãæ£ãããšèŠãªã決å®ä»¥äžã®ãã®ãä¿è·ããå Žåã«ã®ã¿ãå®è³ªçãªå 容ãæã€ã
人éã¯åžžã«èª€ã£ã決å®ãäžããå«ç ãã飲é ããäžæçãªé£äºãåããå±éºãªã¹ããŒããè¡ããæè¡ãæåŠããæ²»çãäžæããæ©äŒãç¡é§ã«ãããããã¯ä»è ãäžæ¡çãšèŠãªããããªãªã¹ã¯ãåŒãåããã
ãã®ããšã¯ãããããæ±ºå®ãæ¯èªããããšã矩åã¥ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
ç§ãã¡ã¯ããããæ¹å€ããããšãã§ããããããã«å察ããè°è«ãå±éããããšãã§ããããã®çµæã«ã€ããŠèŠåããããšãã§ããã
ãããã誰ãã誀ã£ãéžæãããéç«¯ã«æ¶æ» ããŠããŸãèªç±ã¯ãåç®äžã®èªç±ã«ãããªãã
Mill ã¯ãã®ç¹ã«ãããŠãšããã峿 Œã§ããã圌ã¯èªå·±ãžã®å±å®³ãšä»è ã«ããããããå±å®³ãåºå¥ããã ãã§ãªããäž»ãšããŠå人ã«é¢ããè¡çºã«é¢ããŠã¯ããã®è¡åã誀ã£ãŠãããšããä»è ã®èŠè§£ããèªäœã¯ãããã黿¢ããããšãæ£åœåããã®ã«ååã§ã¯ãªããšäž»åŒµããŠããïŒMill, 1859ïŒã
ãã®ååããã¯ãåãå ¥ãã«ãããé¿ããããªãèããå°ãåºãããã
èªå·±ã®äººçã管çããæš©å©ã«ã¯ããããäžå®å šã«ç®¡çããæš©å©ãå«ãŸããŠããã
ãããå¥åº·ã«é©çšãããšæ¬¡ã®ããã«ãªãã
èªå·±ã®å¥åº·ã管çããæš©å©ã«ã¯ããããäžæã«ç®¡çããäœããã®æš©å©ãå«ãŸããŠããªããã°ãªããªãã
ããã§ãªããã°ãå¥åº·ã»å»çäžã®äž»æš©ãªã©ååšããªãããšã«ãªããååšããã®ã¯æ¡ä»¶ä»ãã®èš±å¯ã«ãããªããããªãã¡ããä»è ãååã«ææ ®åå¥ããããšèŠãªããã®ãéžæããŠããéãã«ãããŠãããªãã¯æ±ºå®ã§ããããšããããšã§ããã
çŸä»£ã®çåœå«çåŠã«ã¯ããã®åé¡ã衚çŸããæçšãªæŠå¿µãååšããããªã¹ã¯ã®å°å³ïŒdignity of riskïŒã§ããããã®èãæ¹ã¯ãèªåŸæ§ãã±ã¢ãé害ã«é¢ããè°è«ã«ãããŠç»å Žãããããããªã¹ã¯ãã誰ããä¿è·ããããšãããã®äººç©ããèªå·±æ±ºå®æš©ãå¥ªãææ®µã«ããªãåŸãããšãæãèµ·ããããïŒHulkower, 2022ïŒã
ããã¯ããããããªã¹ã¯ãååçã«åãå ¥ããªããã°ãªããªããšããæå³ã§ã¯ãªãããŸããããããèªå·çè¡çºãå®å šã«èªåŸçãªæ±ºå®ãæ§æãããšããæå³ã§ããªãã
ããéå®çã§ããã€ããå åºãªçµè«ã¯å¥ã«ããã
ãªã¹ã¯ãšç¡èœåã¯ç°ãªãæŠå¿µã§ããã
ããæ±ºå®ã¯å±éºã§ãããªãããåæã«çè§£ãããæ±ºå®ã§ããç¶ããããšãå¯èœã§ããã
ãã人ç©ã¯ãç¹å®ã®è¡çºãèªèº«ã®å¥åº·ã害ããããšãç¥ããªãããä»è ãå ±æããªãçç±ã«ãã£ãŠããã§ããªããããéžå¥œããããšãããã
ãããŠããã«ãå»ççãã¿ãŒããªãºã ã®æãæ ¹æ·±ãé£é¡ã®ã²ãšã€ãååšãããããååã«æå®³ãªæ±ºå®ãããã®äººç©ã«å€æèœåããªãããšã®èšŒæ ãšããŠããèªäœã§å©çšããåŸããšããã°ãæš©åãæ¿èªããªãçµæãçã¿åºãããŸãã«ãã®ç¬éã«ãèªåŸæ§ã¯æ¶æ» ããŠããŸãããšã«ãªãã®ã§ããã
3. ãµãŒãã¹ãšããŠã®å»åŠããæš©åšãšããŠã®å»åŠãž
å»åŠã¯ãæŠå¿µçã«ç°ãªããµãã€ã®æ¹æ³ã§å人ãšé¢ããããšãã§ããã
第äžã®æ¹æ³ã«ãããŠã¯ããµãŒãã¹ãšããŠæ©èœããã
å人ã¯ç¥èãšæŽå©ãæ±ãããå°éå®¶ã¯èšºæãã説æããæšå¥šããæ²»çãæäŸãããç¥èã¯æ£è ã«ãšã£ãŠå©çšå¯èœãªéžæè¢ãæ¡å€§ããã
第äºã®æ¹æ³ã«ãããŠã¯ãå»åŠã¯å¶åºŠçæš©åšã®æ§æ Œã垯ã³ãã
ãã¯ãæ å ±ã®æäŸã«ãšã©ãŸããªããåé¡ããç£èŠããæ£åžžæ§ã®åºæºã確ç«ãã誰ãä»å ¥ãå¿ èŠãšããŠããããå€å®ãããããŠäžå®ã®é åã«ãããŠã¯åäººã®æå¿ã代æ¿ããæ±ºå®ã«é¢äžããããšããã§ããã
äž¡è ã®åœ¢æ ã®éã«çµ¶å¯Ÿçãªå¢çç·ãååšããããã§ã¯ãªããããããå°éè·ã¯ãäœããã®æåçæš©åšãè¡äœ¿ãããåé¡ãçããã®ã¯ããã®å°éçæš©åšãæ£è ã®äººçã«å¯Ÿããç®¡èœæš©ãžãšè»¢åãå§ããæã§ããã
Ivan Illich ã¯ããã®å€å®¹ãåæããããã®æãæ¥é²çãªæ çµã¿ã®ã²ãšã€ãæç€ºããã
å»åç ãšå¥åº·ã®å奪
ãè±ç é¢å瀟äŒãïŒMedical NemesisïŒããã³çåœã®å»çåã«é¢ãã1975幎ã®ãšãã»ã€ã«ãããŠãIllich ã¯ãå»åŠã®åœ±é¿ã¯èšåºçãªæåã®ã¿ã«ãã£ãŠè©äŸ¡ãããããšã¯ã§ããªããšäž»åŒµããããã®å¶åºŠçæ¡å€§èªäœã«ãã£ãŠãããããã害æªã«ã€ããŠãæ€èšããªããã°ãªããªããšããã®ã§ããïŒIllich, 1975ïŒã
èšåºçå»åç ã¯æãæçœãªåœ¢æ ã§ãããããªãã¡ãæ²»çãåŠçœ®ããããã¯å»è¬åã害ãããããå Žåã§ããã
ãããæ¬åæã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ãä»ã®ãµãã€ãããéèŠã§ããã
瀟äŒçåéã®å»åç ã¯ãå»çæ©é¢ãäŸåãçã¿åºãããã€ãŠã¯å¿ ãããå°éç管çãå¿ èŠãšããªãã£ãçµéšã«å¯ŸããŠããã®ç®¡èœæš©ã挞é²çã«æ¡å€§ããæã«çŸããã
æåçåéã®å»åç ã¯ããã«å ãè¡ããããªãã¡ã瀟äŒãèŠçãçŸç ãå 霢ããããã¯æ»ãšãã£ãçµéšãèªãè§£éã管çããèœåãåªå€±ããŠããŸãæããããã
ããããããå¥åº·ã®å奪ãšãã衚çŸã®æ·±é ãªæå³ã§ããã
ããã¯å»åž«ãã¡ãæåéãå¥åº·ããçããããšãæå³ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããåã ã®äººéãå°åå ±åäœããå°éçã·ã¹ãã ãžãšãèœåã»æš©èœããã³æš©åšãç§»è²ã»ç§»è¡ããããšã説æããŠããã®ã§ããã
Illich ã®é説ã¯ããã®ãã¹ãŠã®çµè«ãåãå ¥ããªããšããŠããå¿ã«çããŠãã䟡å€ãããã
å¶åºŠã¯ãã®æè¡çèœåãå¢å€§ãããªãããããã«äŸåãã人ã ã®èªåŸæ§ãåæã«äœäžããåŸãã
Peter Conrad ã¯ãå»çåã®æŠå¿µãéããŠé¢é£ããããã»ã¹ãæ±ã£ãã圌ã®å€å žçãªç·èª¬ã¯ãç¹å®ã®åé¡ãçµéšãããã«ããŠå»åŠçæ çµã¿ã®äžã§å®çŸ©ããæ²»çãããããã«ãªãããåæããå»çåãšç€ŸäŒçµ±å¶ãšã®é¢ä¿ãæç€ºçã«ç ç©¶ããŠããïŒConrad, 1992ïŒã
Irving Zola ã¯ãããããæ©ãããã瀟äŒçµ±å¶ã®æ©èœãç²åŸãåŸãå¶åºŠãšããŠå»åŠãè«ããŠããã圌ã®ããŒãŒã¯ãããããå»çè¡çºã瀟äŒçµ±å¶ã§ãããšãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããå»çã®ç®¡èœæš©ã人çã®ãŸããŸãåºç¯ãªé åãžãšæ¡å€§ãã€ã€ãããšãããã®ã§ãã£ãïŒZola, 1972ïŒã
å°éè·ç€ŸäŒåŠã®ç«å ŽãããEliot Freidson ã¯å°éè·ã®æ¯é ãšããããŒãŒãå±éããå»çå°éè·ã®èªåŸæ§ãšãèªãã®æ¥åã®å®è³ªçåŽé¢ããã³çŸç ã®å®çŸ©ãçµ±å¶ãããã®æŽå²çèœåã匷調ããããã®åŸã®æç®ã§ã¯ããã®æ¯é ãã©ãã»ã©äŸµé£ãããããè°è«ãããŠãããããå»çæš©åãäžå€ã®å®æ°ãšããŠæç€ºããªãããšãèèŠã§ããïŒFreidson ã«é¢ããè°è«ïŒã
ãããã®èŠç¹ã¯ãããæŠå¿µçãªé£éãåæ§ç¯ããããšãå¯èœã«ããã
çµéšãŸãã¯è¡å â å»åŠçå®çŸ© â 蚺æ â å°éçæš©åš â ä»å ¥ã®å¯èœæ§ã
ãã®é£éãå¿ ç¶çã«åŒ·å¶ãçã¿åºãããã§ã¯ãªãã
倧åã®å»çé¢ä¿ã¯ã以äžã§ç«ã¡æ¢ãŸãããšãã§ããã
蚺æ â æšå¥š â åæãŸãã¯æåŠã
粟ç¥å»åŠãç¹å¥ãªå°é£ãããããã®ã¯ãäžå®ã®ç¶æ³äžã«ãããŠããã®é£éãæåŠã®å ãžãšé²è¡ãåŸãããã§ããã
4. éçäºäŸãšããŠã®åŒ·å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠ
åé ãããµãã€ã®çŸå®ãåºå¥ããŠããã®ãé©åã§ããã
èªçºç粟ç¥å»åŠã¯ãä»ã®ãããªãå»çé¢ä¿ãšãåæ§ã«æ©èœãåŸããå人ãå°éå®¶ã«çžè«ããæšå¥šãåãå ¥ãããæåŠããããæ±ºããç¶ç¶ãåžæãããã©ãããèªã決å®ããã
匷å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠã¯ãç°ãªãèŠçŽ ãå°å ¥ããã
ããã¯éèªçºçå ¥é¢ãéé¢ãèº«äœææããããã¯èªåŸæ§ãšèªç±ãå¶éãããã®ä»ã®æªçœ®ã䌎ãåŸããChieze ãã®åºç¯ãªå«ççç·èª¬ã¯ããŸãã«èªåŸæ§ãå®å šæ§ãåè¡ãç¡å±å®³ãæææ±ºå®èœåããããŠæš©åæ¿«çšã®ãªã¹ã¯ã®éã«ããè¡çªãç¹å®ããŠãããåç·èª¬èªäœãæ£è ã«ããæçµ¶ã粟ç¥é害ã®ååšãããããåç¬ã§ã¯æææ±ºå®èœåã®æ¬ åŠãæå³ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšãéèŠãªèŠçŽ ãšããŠæããŠããïŒChieze ã»ãã2021ïŒã
ããã«åé¡ãéçŽãããã
粟ç¥å»åŠãã粟ç¥ããæ±ããä»ã®èšºçç§ãæ±ããªãããã§ã¯ãªãã
ããã§ã¯ãªãã粟ç¥å»åŠçå®è·µã®ç¹å®ã®åœ¢æ ãã以äžãçµã³ã€ãåŸãããã§ããã
èšºææš©åš ïŒ å€æèœåã®è©äŸ¡ ïŒ ãªã¹ã¯è©äŸ¡ ïŒ èªç±ã®å¶é ïŒ æ²»ççä»å ¥ã
Thomas Szasz ã¯ããã®æ¹å€ãã¯ããã«æ¥é²çãªçµè«ãžãšå°ããã
ã匷å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠã«å¯ŸããåçºãïŒThe Case Against Psychiatric CoercionïŒã«ãããŠåœŒã¯ã匷å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠçä»å ¥ããæ¬äººãŸãã¯å ¬è¡ã®ä¿è·ãšããè«æ ãéããŠåœå®¶ã«ãã£ãŠæ£åœåããããæ¬äººã®æå¿ã«åãã蚺æçãŸãã¯æ²»ççãšãããä»å ¥ã®æŒãã€ãã§ãããšå®çŸ©ããŠããïŒSzasz, 1997ïŒã
ãã®åºå¥ã®éèŠæ§ãèªèããããã«ãSzasz ã®çè«ã®ãã¹ãŠãåãå ¥ããå¿ èŠã¯ãªãã
å®ã®ãšããã粟ç¥çŸæ£ã«é¢ããåœŒã®æãè«äºçãªããŒãŒã«äŸåããªãæ¹ãããã®è°è«ã¯ç¥çã«ãã£ãã匷åºãªãã®ãšãªãã
ç§ãã¡ã¯ç æ°ãååšãããšä»®å®ããããšãã§ããã
ç§ãã¡ã¯èšºæãæ£ç¢ºã§ãããšä»®å®ããããšãã§ããã
ç§ãã¡ã¯æ²»çãåªãããã®ã§ãããšä»®å®ããããšãã§ããã
ããã§ããªããå¥ã®åããæ®ãã
ããªããããã®åæããå®åã®è¡äœ¿ãæ£åœåããã®ã«ååã§ããã¯ããããããã
åœŒã®æ²»çåœå®¶ãšããæŠå¿µã¯ããŸãã«ãã®å€å®¹ãææããŠãããããªãã¡ãæš©åãåŠçœ°ãç§©åºã®åã®äžã«ãããŠã®ã¿æ£åœåãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããå¥åº·ã幞çŠã®ä¿è·ãéããŠãæ£åœåããå§ããã®ã§ããã
ãã®ç®çã¯åæã«ãããã®ãããããªãã
ããããã®ããšã¯ãæš©åã®åé¡ãç¡é¢ä¿ã«ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
5. 蚺æãèœåããããŠè§£éã«å¯Ÿããæš©åš
ããäžå±€ã®å³å¯ããå¿ èŠãšããè«ç¹ã®ã²ãšã€ããæææ±ºå®èœåã§ããã
粟ç¥å»åŠç蚺æãšç¡èœåã¯å矩èªã§ã¯ãªãã
çŸä»£ã®å«çæç®ã¯ãäž¡è ã®åé¡ãåé¢ããããšã匷調ããŠãããChieze ãã¯ã粟ç¥é害ã®ååšãæ²»çã®æçµ¶ãããããåç¬ã§ã¯ç¡èœåãæå³ããªããšææããŠãããTilman Steinert ã¯ã圌ã®ã¢ãããŒãã«ãããŠãåæããèœåãå®è³ªçã«æãªãããŠããããã䟵襲æ§ã®äœãææ®µã§ã¯é²ãããšã®ã§ããªãé倧ãªå±éºãååšããå Žåã«ã®ã¿ã匷å¶çæ²»çãæ£åœåããåŸããšäž»åŒµããŠããïŒSteinert, 2017ïŒã
Harry Hudson ã¯èœåãä¿æããŠããå ¥é¢ç²Ÿç¥æ£è ã®äºäŸãçŽæ¥åæããããããäºäŸã«ãããéèªçºçæ²»çã«å¯ŸããŠå察ã®çµè«ãäžããŠããïŒHudson, 2019ïŒã
ããã«ãããåçŽãªæ¯èŒãæç€ºããããšãã§ããã
é節ãªèº«äœçŸæ£ãæ±ããæ£è ã¯ãæ²»çãæåŠããããšãæ»äº¡ãªã¹ã¯ãèããé«ããããšãçè§£ãã€ã€ãèœåãä¿æããŠããéãããããæåŠããæš©å©ãç¶æããããšãã§ããã
ãã粟ç¥ç§ã®æ£è ãä»å ¥ã®æ§è³ªããã®æœåšçå©çããã®ãªã¹ã¯ããããŠãããåãå ¥ããªãããšã®çµæãçè§£ããŠãããªãã°ã蚺æãååšãããšããåãªãäºå®ããèªäœã¯ããªããã®æçµ¶ãããäœãè©äŸ¡ãããã¹ããªã®ãã説æããªãã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ èšºæãæ²»çãžã®æçµ¶ããããã¯å±éºãªæ±ºå®ã¯ããããåç¬ã§ã¯ç¡èœåã蚌æããªãããã人ç©ã®æå¿ã代æ¿ããåã«ãåå¥å ·äœçãªäºäŸã«ãããŠãã®æææ±ºå®èœåãè©äŸ¡ãããããå¶éçã§ãªãä»£æ¿ææ®µãæ€èšãããªããã°ãªããªãã
ç èïŒinsightïŒã®åé¡
ãããããããã«ç¹çްãªåé¡ãçŸãããç èïŒinsightïŒã§ããã
ç èã®æ¬ åŠãæ¶ç©ºã®ãã®ã§ãããšäž»åŒµããããšã¯çå£ãªè°è«ãšã¯ãããªãã ãããããã¯å®åšããèšåºæŠå¿µã§ãããç¹å®ã®ç¶æ ã¯ãã人ç©ãèªãã®ç¶æ³ã®è«žåŽé¢ãèªèããèœåãæ·±ãæãªãåŸãã
åé¡ã¯å¶åºŠçãªãã®ã§ããã
次ã®ãããªæ§é ãçãåŸãã
å°éå®¶ã蚺æãäžã â æ£è ããããæåŠãã â ãã®æçµ¶ãç èæ¬ åŠã®ãããªã蚌æ ãšããŠè§£éããã â æ£è ã®æçµ¶ã®ä¿¡ææ§ãäœäžããã
ããã§ã¯ããã®é£éãå¿ ç¶çã«çãããšããåžžã«èª€ãã§ãããšäž»åŒµããŠããããã§ã¯ãªãã
ç°è«ãšãããã®ã¯ãããã埪ç°è«æ³çãªæœåšçå¯èœæ§ãåãã§ãããšããç¹ã§ãããããªãã¡ãä»å ¥ãäŒãŠãåäžã®æš©åšãããã®ä»å ¥ãžã®å察ãè§£éããããã®èªèè«çæš©åããææ¡ãåŸãã®ã§ããã
ããã§ãMiranda Fricker ã®èªèçäžæ£çŸ©ïŒepistemic injusticeïŒãšããæŠå¿µãæçšãšãªããPaul CrichtonãHavi Carelãããã³ Ian James Kidd ã¯ããã粟ç¥å»åŠã«çŽæ¥é©çšãã粟ç¥é害ãæã€äººã ã¯ãéåçæ§ãä¿¡é Œæ§ã®æ¬ åŠãšããåºå®èŠ³å¿µã®ããã«ããã®èšŒèšã«å¯Ÿããä¿¡ææ§ãäœãèŠç©ããããããšã«å¯ŸããŠãšãããè匱ã«ãªãåŸããšäž»åŒµããŠããïŒCrichtonãCarelãKiddã2017ïŒã
ãã®ããšã¯ãæ¹å€ãããç確ã«å®åŒåããããšãå¯èœã«ããã
æ£è ãåžžã«æ£ãããšäž»åŒµããããšã§ã¯ãªãã
å°éå®¶ã®è§£éãå¿ ç¶çã«æ¯é ã®åœ¢æ ã§ãããšäž»åŒµããããšã§ããªãã
é察称æ§ãèªèããããšãåé¡ãªã®ã§ããã
èªç±ã奪ããã人ç©ã¯ãæããäžä¿¡ãæ±ããæè°ããéé¢ãèŠæ±ãããããã¯ååãæããããããªãã
ãããã®è¡åã¯èšåºçãªæ å ±ãå«ãã§ããå¯èœæ§ãããã
ããããã®äžéšã¯ãå¶éãã®ãã®ã«å¯Ÿããçè§£å¯èœãªåå¿ã§ããããããããªãã
åé¡ãçŸããã®ã¯ãããå¶åºŠããã®ç¶æ³ãçã¿åºãæš©åãšãããã«å¯Ÿããåå¿ã®æå³ãå ¬åŒã«æ±ºå®ã¥ããæš©åšãšãåæã«ææ¡ããŠããæã§ããã
6. å ¥é¢ãæœèšããããŠç©ççå®åãè¶ ãã匷å¶
éèªçºçå ¥é¢ãšèªç±ã®å¶é
éèªçºçå ¥é¢ã«ã¯æ²»çç®çãããã
åæã«èªç±ããå¶éããã
åæ¹ã®äž»åŒµãåæã«çã§ããåŸãã
ãã人ç©ãæœèšãé¢ããããšãæãã§ããã«ããããããããããé»ãæ³çãŸãã¯ç©ççãªæš©åšã»æš©åæ©æ§ãååšãããªãã°ãç§ãã¡ã¯èªç±ã®å¶éã«çŽé¢ããŠããã®ã§ãããããããã«å«çæç®ã¯ãéèªçºçå容ãåãªãèšåºç圢æ ãšããŠã§ã¯ãªããåå¥å ·äœçãªå«ççã»æ³çæ£åœåãèŠæ±ããä»å ¥ãšããŠæ±ã£ãŠããïŒChieze ã»ãã2021ïŒã
Goffman ãšæš©åã®å¶åºŠçéäž
Erving Goffman ã¯ãã¢ãµã€ã©ã ãïŒAsylumsïŒã«ãããŠãæ§æå¡ã®æ¥åžžç掻ã®å€§åãå ±éã®ç®¡çæš©åšã®äžã§çµç¹ãããç°å¢ãç ç©¶ããããã«ãå šå¶çæœèšïŒtotal institutionïŒãšããæŠå¿µãå±éããã
Goffman ã®æåãçŸä»£ã®ãããã粟ç¥ç§ç æ£ã«æ©æ¢°çã«åœãŠã¯ããã®ã¯äžé©åã§ãããã
ãã®æçšæ§ã¯å¥ã®ãšããã«ãããããªãã¡ãåæçãªåããæäŸãããšããç¹ã§ããã
ããã®æœèšã¯ããã人ç©ã®ç掻ã®ããã€ã®æ¬¡å ãåæã«çµ±å¶ããŠããã®ãã
- ç§»åã
- æéå²ïŒæ¥èª²ïŒã
- ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒã
- ææåã
- é¢äŒã
- éä¿¡ã
- æ²»çã
- ãã®å Žæãç«ã¡å»ãå¯èœæ§ã
ãããã®æš©éã®éäžã倧ãããã°å€§ããã»ã©ãå¶åºŠçãªé察称æ§ã¯å¢å€§ããå€éšã«ããçµ±å¶ã¯ãã£ããéèŠã§ããã¯ãã§ããã
éä¿¡ã«ã¯ç¹å¥ãªæ³šæãæãå¿ èŠããããé»è©±ã®ããããå¶éãäžåœã§ãããšäž»åŒµããæ ¹æ ã¯ãªããå®å šããã©ã€ãã·ãŒããããã¯èšåºçéå¶äžã®å ·äœçãªçç±ãååšãåŸããããããå ¥é¢ããŠãããããšãã£ãŠããããã远å çå¶éãèªåçã«åé¡èŠããã«å€ããªããšèŠãªãããã¹ãã§ããªãã
ãã®åãã¯åå¥ã«æèµ·ãããªããã°ãªããªãã
ããã®å ·äœçãªå¶éã¯ããã®äººç©ã«å¯ŸããŠããã®æéã«ãããããããŠãã®çç±ã®ããã«å¿ èŠãªã®ãã
åæ§ã®åæã¯ä»ã®å¶éã«ãåœãŠã¯ãŸãã
ã€ã³ãã©ãŒãã«ãªåŒ·å¶ãšå®è³ªçãªèªçºæ§
ããã«ã匷å¶ã¯ç®ã«èŠããå®åã®è¡äœ¿ãªãã«ãååšãåŸãã
éèªçºçå ¥é¢ã®æ±ºå®ã«é¢ãã系統çã¬ãã¥ãŒããã³ã¡ã¿çµ±åã¯ãåœäºè ã«ãšã£ãŠäœãæåã§ããããç¥ã£ãŠãããšä¿¡ããå°éå®¶ã«ãã匷å¶ã®æ£åœåã«å ããåœäºè ãä»è·è ãå°éå®¶ã®éã«ãããã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ã®åé¡ãæš©åã®äžåè¡¡ãèŠåºããŠããïŒSugiuraãPertegaãHolmbergã2020ïŒã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ åœ¢åŒçãªåæã¯ãå¿ ãããå®è³ªçãªèªçºæ§ãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªããéžæè¢ã®å®éã®æ§é ãä»å ¥ãåãå ¥ãããããããã¯é倧ãªå¶åºŠççµæã«çŽé¢ãããã§ãããªãã°ã眲åã²ãšã€ã§åé¡ã解決ããããã§ã¯ãªãã
ããããèšåºç亀æžã匷å¶ãæ§æããããã§ã¯ãªããããããå¶åºŠçãªè åšã®äžã§åŸãããå諟ããããããèªç±ãªæ±ºå®ãšããŠåçŽã«èšè¿°ãã¹ããšããããã§ããªãã
7. èªå·ãä»è å±å®³ããããŠå±éºæ§
æ··ä¹±ã®æå€§ã®åå ã®ã²ãšã€ã¯ãé埳çã«ç°ãªããµãã€ã®ç¶æ³ããå±éºæ§ããšããåäžã®æŠå¿µã®äžã«äžæ¬ãã«ããããšã«ããã
第äžã®ç¶æ³ã¯ä»¥äžã®éãã§ããã
ãã®äººç©ãèªåèªèº«ãå·ã€ããå¯èœæ§ãããã
第äºã®ç¶æ³ã¯ä»¥äžã®éãã§ããã
ãã®äººç©ãä»ã®äººã ã«å±å®³ãå ããå¯èœæ§ãããã
å±å®³ååã«åºã¥ã芳ç¹ããèŠãã°ãäž¡è ã¯ç䟡ã§ã¯ãªãã
èªå·±ãžã®å±å®³
ããã¯ãã¿ãŒããªãºã ã®å žåçãªäºäŸã§ããã
ãã®æžå¿µã¯å®å šã«åççã§ããåŸãããã人ç©ãé倧ãªå±æ©ã«çŽé¢ããŠããããšãããåŸãã
ãããããªã¹ã¯ã®ååšã¯äŸç¶ãšããŠç°ãªããµãã€ã®åãã解決ããªãã
- ãã®äººç©ã¯èµ·ããŠããäºæ ãçè§£ããèœåãç¶æããŠãããã
- ããç¶æããŠãããšããã°ããããªãæ ¹æ ã«ãã£ãŠãã®æ±ºå®ã代æ¿ããããšãèš±ãããã®ãã
æå®³ãªãã®ãéžæãããšããåãªãäºå®ã¯ãç¡èœåã蚌æããªãã
ããã§ãªããã°ãèª°ãæ±ºå®æš©ãæã€ãã倿ããããã«ã決å®ã®å 容ã埪ç°è«æ³çãªåºæºãšããŠå©çšããããšã«ãªã£ãŠããŸãã
ããããã匷åºãªåºå¥ãç¶æããããšãæãŸããã
ãªã¹ã¯ã¯ç¡èœåãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
ããã¯ãèœåã®å®è³ªçãªåªå€±ãååšããå Žåã®ç·æ¥ä»å ¥ãåŠå®ããããšã矩åã¥ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããæå®³ãªæ±ºå®ããç¡èœåã®èªåçãªç䟡ç©ãžãšè»¢åãããªãããšã矩åã¥ããŠããã®ã§ããã
ä»è ãžã®å±å®³
ããã§ã¯è°è«ã®æ§çžãå€ããã
Mill ã¯ãŸãã«ãä»è ãžã®å±å®³ã®é²æ¢ããå人ã®èªç±ãå¶éããããã®æã匷åºãªæ ¹æ ãšããŠèªããŠããïŒMill, 1859ïŒã
ããã粟ç¥å»åŠã«ãããŠã¯ã远å ã®åé¡ãçŸãããç§ãã¡ã¯ãã°ãã°ããã§ã«çºçããå±å®³ã§ã¯ãªãããªã¹ã¯ã®äºæž¬ã«ã€ããŠèªã£ãŠããã®ã§ããã
ããã¯ãèªç±ã®å¥å¥ªãå°æ¥ã®è¡åã«é¢ãã確çè«çæšå®ã«äŸåãåŸãããšãæå³ããã
ãããŠã確çè«çäºæž¬ã¯èª€ãå¯èœæ§ãããã
ããããã«ãä»è ã®ä¿è·ãã¯ããã«åŒ·åãªæ£åœåãæäŸãããšããŠãã以äžã«é¢ããåãã¯äŸç¶ãšããŠéèŠã§ããç¶ããã
- ãªã¹ã¯ã®åè¿«æ§ãšåŒ·åºŠã
- å©çšå¯èœãªèšŒæ ã
- å¶éã®æéã
- æ¯äŸæ§ã
- ç¬ç«ãã審æ»ã
- ããå¶éçã§ãªãä»£æ¿ææ®µã
ãããã®èŠä»¶ã¯ãæ³ã®æ¯é ã®ããäžè¬çãªååã«ã€ãªããããã人ç©ã«å¯Ÿããæš©åã®å¹²æžãæ·±å»ã§ããã°ããã»ã©ãèŠåãæç¶ãã審æ»ããããŠè£éã®å¶éã®éèŠæ§ã¯å¢å€§ããªããã°ãªããªãã
ä»è ã®ä¿è·ã匷å¶ãæ£åœåãåŸãããšãèªããããšã¯ãå±éºæ§ã®ãããªãåºæºããåãå ¥ããããšã矩åã¥ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
8. å®¶æãšç¬¬äžè ïŒå¿é ã¯äž»æš©ã§ã¯ãªã
粟ç¥å»åŠçæš©åã¯ãåžžã«å»åž«ãå ¬åå¡ã«ãã£ãŠã®ã¿çºåãããããã§ã¯ãªãã
å®¶æã¯å±æ©ã®éã«éèŠãªåœ¹å²ãæããããšããããããã¯çè§£ã§ããããšã§ãããè¡åã«ãããæè¿ã®å€åãæãããç¥ãè ãæžå¿µãã¹ãäºæ ãç®æããè ããããã¯ã±ã¢ã®çžåœãªè² æ ãæ ã£ãŠããè ã¯ãå€ãã®å Žåå®¶æã§ããã
ãããã芪æé¢ä¿ãèªåŸæ§ã®åé¡ãåž³æ¶ãã«ããããã§ã¯ãªãã
ãã芪æãä»ã®äººç©ãæ·±ãæããŠããªããããã®äººç©ãå¿ èŠãšããŠãããã®ã«ã€ããŠèª€ãããšãããåŸãã
è¡åãåã£ãŠè§£éããããšãããã
èªãã®å©å®³é¢ä¿ãæã£ãŠããããšãããã
察ç«ãååšããããšãããã
ãããã¯åã«ãèªããä»å ¥ããããšããŠãã人ç©ããããå®å šãã¯ããã«é«ãè©äŸ¡ããŠããã ããããããªãã
ç ç©¶ã瀺ããŠããã®ã¯ããŸãã«æ£è ãšä»è·è ãåäžã®å ¥é¢ã倧ããç°ãªã£ãŠäœéšãåŸããšããããšã§ãããRanieri ãã®ç ç©¶ã«ãããŠãéèªçºçã«å ¥é¢ããããã人ã ã®ä»è·è ã¯ãæ£è æ¬äººãã¡ããããã®å ¥é¢ãåŒ·å¶æ§ãäœããæç¶ãçã«ããå ¬æ£ã§ãããšèªèããŠããïŒRanieri ã»ãã2015ïŒã
ããã¯å®¶æãæªæãæã£ãŠè¡åããŠããããšã蚌æãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
ãããããé¢é£æ§ã®é«ãäºå®ã瀺ããŠããã
ä¿è·ããæå³ãšã匷å¶ãããŠãããšããçµéšã¯å ±åãåŸãã
Sugiura ãã®ç·èª¬ã¯ããã«ãéèªçºçå ¥é¢ã®æç¶ãã®éçšã«ãããŠãåœäºè ãä»è·è ãå°éå®¶ã®éã«ããã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³äžã®åé¡ãæš©åã®äžåè¡¡ãèŠåºããŠããïŒSugiuraãPertegaãHolmbergã2020ïŒã
ããããå°ãåºããåŸãèŠç¯çãªçµè«ã¯æç¢ºã§ããã
芪æé¢ä¿ã¯çµã責任ããããŠæœåšçã«äŸ¡å€ããæ å ±ãçã¿åºãããä»ã®æäººã«å¯Ÿãã䞻暩ãçã¿åºãããã§ã¯ãªãã
å¿é ããããšãå©èšããããšã説åŸããããšãè©äŸ¡ãæ±ããããšãšãä»è ã®æå¿ã代æ¿ãåŸãã¡ã«ããºã ãå®è³ªçã«ææ¡ããããšãšã®éã«ã¯ãæç¢ºãªéããååšããã
å®¶æéãçµæžçãå®¶åºå ããããã¯è²¡ç£äžã®çŽäºãååšããå Žåããã®åé¡ã¯ãã£ããã®æ éããèŠæ±ããã
粟ç¥å»åŠããããã®çŽäºã«ãããŠæ¥åžžçã«éå ·ãšããŠå©çšãããŠãããšäž»åŒµããæ ¹æ ã¯ãªãã
å¶åºŠçãªè°è«ã¯ç°ãªãã
ãã第äžè ã®é³è¿°ã誰ãã®èªç±ã«é倧ãªçµæãããããæªçœ®ãçºåãããäžå ãšãªãåŸãã®ã§ããã°ãã·ã¹ãã ã¯èª€ã£ãæ å ±ãèªåŒµãããæ å ±ãç¹å®ã®å©å®³ã«åºã¥ãæ å ±ããããã¯ç«¯çã«èåœã§ããæ å ±ã«èããããã®ã§ãªããã°ãªããªãã
ãã¹ãŠã®å®¶æãåãã€ãããã§ã¯ãªãã
ããã§ã¯ãªãããŸãšããªã·ã¹ãã ã§ããã°ããã¹ãŠã®æ å ±æäŸè ãäžç«ã§ãããšãã仮説ã«äŸåãã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãããã§ããã
9. åŒ·å¶æè¬ã身äœã®å®å šæ§ããããŠåæ
éèªçºçå ¥é¢ã¯ãäž»ãšããŠç§»åã®èªç±ã«åœ±é¿ãåãŒãã
éèªçºçæè¬ã¯ãããã«çäœãžã®çŽæ¥çãªä»å ¥ãå°å ¥ããã
粟ç¥å»åŠã«ãããŠãè¬å€ã¯ççåŠçãè¡åçããããŠäž»èгçãªå€åãããããåŸããJoanna Moncrieff ãš David Cohen ã¯ãè¬å€ãç çåŠçããã»ã¹ã«äœçšãããšèŠãªããçŸæ£äžå¿ã¢ãã«ããšãç©è³ªãã®ãã®ã«ãã£ãŠããããããççåŠçãè¡åçã䞻芳ç广ããã³ãã®èšåºçæçšæ§ã®å¯èœæ§ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠããè¬ç©äžå¿ã¢ãã«ããšãåºå¥ããŠããïŒMoncrieffãCohenã2005ïŒã
è¬ç©çæ³ã«ã€ããŠã®ååãªæ å ±ã«åºã¥ãåæã«å¿ èŠãªãã®
ããéå®ãããçµè«ãå°ãåºãããã«ãMoncrieff ã®çè«ãå šé¢çã«æ¡çšããå¿ èŠã¯ãªãã
è¬ç©çæ³ãžã®åæã«ã¯ããã®å»è¬åã«ã©ã®ãããªå¹æãæåŸ ããããããªãå©çã远æ±ããããããªããªã¹ã¯ãæå®³äºè±¡ãååšããã®ãã«ã€ããŠã®ååã«æ£ç¢ºãªæ å ±ãå¿ èŠã§ããã
ããã¯å粟ç¥è¬ã«å察ããè°è«ã§ã¯ãªãã
è«ç¹ã¯ç°ãªãã
åã³æã奜éœåãªã·ããªãªãä»®å®ããŠã¿ããã
è¬ã¯å¹ããŠããã
å»åž«ã¯ãããçç¢ºã«æšå¥šããŠããã
æ£è ã¯ãã®æ å ±ãçè§£ããŠããã
ãããŠããããæåŠããã
ãã®æãåäžã®åé¡ãåã³çŸããã
ãæ£ç¢ºãªæ²»çé©å¿ããæçµ¶ã«æããŠç©ççã«ä»å ¥ããããã®æš©åšã»æš©éãžãšå€ãããã®ã¯äœãªã®ãã
åœäºè ãçã«èœåãæ¬ ããŠããå Žåã«ã¯ãåå¥å ·äœçãªèŠåãå¿ èŠãšããå¥ã®åé¡ãååšããã
èœåãä¿æããŠããå Žåã身äœç䞻暩ãšã®ç·åŒµé¢ä¿ã¯ã¯ããã«çŽæ¥çãªãã®ãšãªãã
10. 匷å¶ããæš©å©ã®ãã©ãã€ã ãž
æå¿ã®ä»£æ¿ã«å¯Ÿãããªã«ã¿ããã£ã
匷å¶ãžã®æ¹å€ã¯ãæŸçœ®ãæè·ããããšã矩åã¥ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
ããã¯èª€ã£ãäºè æäžã§ããã
屿©ã®éã«ãããæ¬äººã®åå ãé«ããããã«ãŸãã«èšèšãããã¡ã«ããºã ãååšããã
- äºåèšç»ã
- 粟ç¥ç§äºåæç€ºæžã
- å°åæ¯æŽã
- æææ±ºå®æ¯æŽïŒæ¯æŽä»ãæææ±ºå®ïŒã
- äºåã«éžã°ããä¿¡é Œã§ãã人ç©ã
- 審æ»ããã³åå ã®æç¶ãã
ããããèªå·±æææç€ºæžïŒself-binding directivesïŒã¯ããšãããè€éãªäºäŸã§ããããã©ã³ã»ããã»ãµã€ã«ã€ã¢ããªãŒãïŒThe Lancet PsychiatryïŒã«æ²èŒããã系統çã¬ãã¥ãŒã¯ãè³åŠåæ¹ã®è°è«ãèŠåºããŠãããè¯å®çãªè°è«ãšããŠã¯èªåŸæ§ãå±å®³ã®äœæžã匷å¶ã®æœåšçãªæžå°ãæããããåŠå®çãªè°è«ãšããŠã¯èªåŸæ§ãã®ãã®ãžã®ãªã¹ã¯ãèœåã宿œã«ãããå°é£ãæœåšçãªå®³æªãæããããŠããïŒStephenson ã»ãã2023ïŒã
ãããã£ãŠãããããçŽç²ã«é匷å¶çãªè§£æ±ºçãšããŠç¡éªæ°ã«æç€ºãã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãã
éèŠãªã®ã¯ãå³åº§ã«æ±ºå®ã®ä»£æ¿ãåæãšããã®ã§ã¯ãªããæ¬äººã®æå¿ãšéžå¥œãä¿å šããããšè©Šã¿ãã¢ãã«ãååšãããšããããšã§ããã
æš©å©ã®ãã©ãã€ã ãžã®è»¢æ
ãã®è°è«ã¯ããã«ãåœéäººæš©ã®æ¬¡å ããç²åŸããŠããã
éå®³è æš©å©æ¡çŽã¯ãèªåŸæ§ãå¹³çããããŠæ³çèœåããã®äžå¿ååã«äœçœ®ã¥ããŠãããåæ¡çŽã®å§å¡äŒã¯ãæ³åŸã®åã«ã²ãšããèªããããæš©å©ããã³æææ±ºå®æ¯æŽã«é¢ãã第12æ¡ã«ã€ããŠããšããã峿 Œãªè§£éãå±éããŠããã
ããã§éèŠãªæ³çæç¢ºåãè¡ã£ãŠããå¿ èŠãããã
å§å¡äŒã®è§£éã¯ãååœã®çŸè¡åœå æ³ãšèªåçã«åçã«ãªãããã§ã¯ãªãããããã®ç«å ŽãšãäŸç¶ãšããŠäžå®ã®èŠä»¶ã®äžã§éèªçºçå ¥é¢ãæ²»çãèªããŠããå€ãã®åœå æ³å¶ãšã®éã«ã¯ãå°ãªããã¬éãããååšããã
ããããæ³çåŠçãªèгç¹ããèŠãã°ããã®ç«å Žã¯èãã匷åã§ããã
äžçä¿å¥æ©é¢ïŒWHOïŒããã³åœé£äººæš©é«çåŒåå®äºåæïŒOHCHRïŒã¯ã2023幎ã«ãããªãéèŠãªäžæ©ãèžã¿åºãããå ±åã¬ã€ãã³ã¹ã§ãããã¡ã³ã¿ã«ãã«ã¹ã人暩ããã³æ³å¶ïŒæéãšå®è·µãïŒMental Health, Human Rights and Legislation: Guidance and PracticeïŒã¯ãéèªçºçå ¥é¢ãåŒ·å¶æ²»çãéé¢ãèº«äœææãšãã£ãæ £è¡ãå«ãã¡ã³ã¿ã«ãã«ã¹ãµãŒãã¹ã«ããã匷å¶ãæ€å»ããèªç±ãã€ååãªæ å ±ã«åºã¥ãåæã𿝿Žã¢ãã«ãã±ã¢ã®äžå¿ã«æ®ããããšãç®æããæ¹é©ãæå±ããŠããïŒWHOã»OHCHRã2023ïŒã
ãããã£ãŠã匷å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠã«å¯Ÿããæ¹å€ã¯ããã¯ãåãªã20äžçŽã®ãå粟ç¥å»åŠãã®å¥ç¯ãªäž»åŒµãšããŠçã¥ããããšã¯ã§ããªãã
仿¥ã§ã¯ã匷å¶ã«çŽæ¥ç°è°ãå±ããæå¿ã®ä»£æ¿ãäžå¿ãšããã¢ãã«ããèªåŸæ§ãæ¯æŽããããŠæš©å©ã«åºã¥ãã·ã¹ãã ãžãšçœ®ãæããããšãæèšããåœéçãªå¶åºŠç朮æµãååšããŠããã
11. æ ¹æ¬çãªåé¡ïŒç¥èã®ç®¡èœæš©ãžã®è»¢å
æ¿æ²»å²åŠãå»ç瀟äŒåŠãçåœå«çåŠããããŠç²Ÿç¥å»åŠã蟿ã£ãŠããä»ãåé¡ã¯ããªãç°¡æœã«å®åŒåããããšãã§ããã
å»åŠã¯å°éç¥èãæããŠããã
ãã®ç¥èã¯æ£åœãªèªèè«çæš©åšãçã¿åºãã
瀟äŒã¯å°éè·ãç é¢ããããŠèŠå¶ã·ã¹ãã ãéããŠããã®æš©åšãå¶åºŠåããããšãã§ããã
ãããŸã§ã¯ãå¿ ãããåé¡ãçããããã§ã¯ãªãã
å±éºãçŸããã®ã¯ããã®é£éã以äžã®ããã«ç¶ãæã§ããã
å°éç¥è â å°éçæš©åš â å¶åºŠçç®¡èœæš© â æ±ºå®ã®ä»£æ¿ â 匷å¶ã
å¥ã®å¯èœãªé£éãååšããã
å°éç¥è â æ å ±æäŸ â æšå¥š â æ£è ã®æ±ºå® â åæã«åºã¥ãæ²»çã
äž¡è ã®éãã¯ãå»åž«ãã©ãã»ã©ç¥ã£ãŠãããã«ããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
誰ãæåŸã®æ±ºå®æš©ãä¿æããŠãããã«ããã
ãã®ããšã¯ããªãä»å ¥ã®æå¹æ§ããèªäœãè°è«ã解決ããªãã®ãã説æããŠããã
ããä»å ¥ã¯ç§åŠçã«æ£ç¢ºã§ãããªãããæ¿æ²»çã«åé¡å«ã¿ã§ããåŸãã
å©çããããããªãããäŸç¶ãšããŠèªåŸæ§ã䟵害ãç¶ããããšãããåŸãã
åæã«çæ³ãåŸãŠããªãããäŸç¶ãšããŠéå°ãªæš©åãéäžããç¶ããããšãããåŸãã
å¶åºŠçéçãå¿ èŠãšãããã®ã¯ãæªæãæã£ã人ã ãååšãããããšããçç±ã ãã«ãšã©ãŸããªãã
ããããå¿ èŠãšãããã®ã¯ããŸãã«åãè¡ã£ãŠãããšç¢ºä¿¡ããŠãã人ã ããŸãèªãã®æš©éãéžè±ãåŸãããã§ããã
12. å人ã®éå ·ãšããŠã®å»åŠ
å»åŠã¯äººé¡ã®æŽå²ã«ãããŠæãå倧ãªé²æ©ã®ããã€ããæãéããŠããããŸãã«ããããã«ãå»åŠã¯ãã®éçã«é¢ããçå£ãªçè«ã«å€ããã®ã§ããã
å»ççç¥èãé«ãè©äŸ¡ããããšãšãããã匷å¶çæš©åãžãšè»¢åããããšãèŠæããããšãšã®éã«ãççŸã¯ååšããªãã
å人ã«åããããå»çã¯ãèªãã®ç¶æ³ãçè§£ããéžæè¢ãæ¯èŒããæ±ºå®ãäžãããã®æ¬äººã®èœåãé«ãããã®ã§ããã¹ãã§ããã
èªåŸæ§ã¯ãåãå ¥ããããçµæãåãå ¥ããããšãæå³ãããããªãã¡ãä»ã®æäººãã¡ããç§ãã¡ã誀ãã§ãããšèŠãªããããªæ±ºå®ãäžããšããããšã§ããã
ãã®äžã«ã¯ãå®éã«èª€ã£ãŠãããã®ãããã ããã
害ããããããã®ãããã ããã
ä»ã®èª°ãã圌ãã«ä»£ãã£ãŠæ±ºå®ãäžããŠãããªãã°ãããããããè¯ãçµæããããããã§ããããã®ããããããããªãã
ããããæå®³ãªæ±ºå®ã®åãªãå¯èœæ§ãããã人ç©ã«å¯Ÿããæš©åšãä»è ã«è²æž¡ããã®ã«ååã§ãããšããã°ãå人ã®äž»æš©ã«ã¯ã»ãšãã©äœã®å®è³ªçæå³ããªããªã£ãŠããŸãã
ããããã«ãããã€ãã®åºå¥ãæç¢ºã«ããŠããããšãæãŸããã
- ç¥èã¯ç®¡èœæš©ãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
- åè¡ã¯åŒ·å¶ã®æ£åœæ§ãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
- 蚺æã¯ç¡èœåãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
- ãªã¹ã¯ã¯ç¡èœåãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
- 説åŸããããšã¯åŒ·å¶ããããšãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
- 誰ããå¿é ããããšã¯ããã®äººç©ã«å¯Ÿãã䞻暩è ã§ããããšãšå矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
匷å¶ç²Ÿç¥å»åŠããšããã峿 Œãªç£èŠã«å€ããã®ã¯ã蚺æãèœåãèªç±ãæ²»çããããŠå人èªèº«ã®è¡åã®è§£éã«å¯Ÿããæš©åšã»æš©éãäžèº«ã«éäžããåŸãããã§ããã
ããã¯ãããããéèªçºçä»å ¥ãå¿ ç¶çã«äžåœã§ããããšã蚌æãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
ããããåã«å»åŠçãæ²»ççããããã¯ä¿è·çãšç§°ãããŠãããšããçç±ã ãã§ããããªãä»å ¥ãæ£åœãšèŠãªãããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãããšãæå³ããŠããã
æ£åœåã®ç«èšŒè²¬ä»»ã¯ãä»è ã®æå¿ã代æ¿ããããšããè ã®åŽã«èª²ãããªããã°ãªããªãã
ãããŠãã®è²¬ä»»ã¯ããã®äººç©ã®èªç±ã身äœã®å®å šæ§ããããŠèªåŸæ§ã«å¯Ÿããä»å ¥ã®åŒ·åºŠã«æ¯äŸããŠå¢å€§ããã¹ãã§ããã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ å»åŠã¯ããããããã®ç¥èã人éã®ããã«åœ¹ç«ãŠãæã«æå€§ã®æ£åœæ§ãç²åŸããããã®ç¥èãåœäººã«å¯Ÿããäž»æš©ã®æ ¹æ ãžãšå€ããŠããŸãæãæ£åœåããããšã¯ã¯ããã«å°é£ãšãªãã
åèæç®ããã³æ å ±æº
- Mill, John Stuart. On Liberty (1859). Project Gutenberg.
- Dworkin, Gerald. âPaternalismâ. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- Hulkower, Adira. âA Place of His Own: Applying Dignity of Risk to Bioethics Consultationâ. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 65(2) (2022): 232â241. doi: 10.1353/pbm.2022.0019.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. âCoercionâ.
- Illich, Ivan. Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of Health (1975).
- Illich, Ivan. âThe Medicalization of Lifeâ (1975).
- Conrad, Peter. âMedicalization and Social Controlâ. Annual Review of Sociology 18 (1992): 209â232.
- Zola, Irving K. âMedicine as an Institution of Social Controlâ. The Sociological Review (1972).
- Freidson, Eliot. Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge (1970).
- Chieze, Marie; Clavien, Christine; Kaiser, Stefan; Hurst, Samia. âCoercive Measures in Psychiatry: A Review of Ethical Argumentsâ. Frontiers in Psychiatry 12 (2021): 790886. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.790886.
- Szasz, Thomas. âThe Case Against Psychiatric Coercionâ. The Independent Review 1(4) (1997): 485â498. The Independent Review.
- Szasz, Thomas. Law, Liberty and Psychiatry (1963).
- Steinert, Tilman. âEthics of Coercive Treatment and Misuse of Psychiatryâ. Psychiatric Services 68(3) (2017): 291â294. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201600066.
- Hudson, Harry. âCoercion in Psychiatry: Is It Right to Involuntarily Treat Inpatients with Capacity?â Journal of Medical Ethics 45(11) (2019): 742â745. doi: 10.1136/medethics-2019-105357.
- Fricker, Miranda. Epistemic Injustice: Power and the Ethics of Knowing (2007).
- Crichton, Paul; Carel, Havi; Kidd, Ian James. âEpistemic Injustice in Psychiatryâ. BJPsych Bulletin 41(2) (2017): 65â70. doi: 10.1192/pb.bp.115.050682.
- Goffman, Erving. Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates (1961).
- Sugiura, Kanna; Pertega, Elvira; Holmberg, Christopher. âExperiences of Involuntary Psychiatric Admission Decision-Making: A Systematic Review and Meta-Synthesis of the Perspectives of Service Users, Informal Carers, and Professionalsâ. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 73 (2020): 101645. doi: 10.1016/j.ijlp.2020.101645.
- Ranieri, Veronica et al. âCaregivers' Perceptions of Coercion in Psychiatric Hospital Admissionâ. Psychiatry Research 228(3) (2015): 380â385. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2015.05.079.
- Moncrieff, Joanna; Cohen, David. âRethinking Models of Psychotropic Drug Actionâ. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 74(3) (2005): 145â153. doi: 10.1159/000083999.
- Stephenson, Lucy; Gieselmann, Astrid; Gergel, Tania; Owen, Gareth; Gather, Jakov; Scholten, Matthé. âSelf-binding Directives in Psychiatric Practice: A Systematic Review of Reasonsâ. The Lancet Psychiatry 10 (2023): 887â895. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(23)00221-3.
- United Nations. Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
- Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. General Comment No. 1 (2014), Article 12: Equal Recognition before the Law.
- World Health Organization & Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. Mental Health, Human Rights and Legislation: Guidance and Practice (2023).
Libertatis Venezuela ã§ã®é¢é£èšäº
- å人ã®äž»æš©ïŒããã¯ãããªããã®ã§ãããèªç±ãšããã«é¢é£ããã®ã
- å人ã®èªåŸæ§ïŒäœãæå³ãããªãèªç±ãªç€ŸäŒã«ãšã£ãŠéèŠãªã®ã
- åœå®¶ã®åŒ·å¶ïŒããã¯ãããªããã®ã§ããããªãèªç±äž»çŸ©ã«ãšã£ãŠã®æžå¿µãšãªãã®ã
- å人ã®èªç±ïŒããã¯ãããªããã®ã§ããããªãèªç±äž»çŸ©ã«ãšã£ãŠäžå¿çãªã®ã
- æ³ã®æ¯é ïŒããã¯ãããªããã®ã§ããããªãèªç±ãä¿è·ããã®ã
å ±æ