æ³ã®åªäœãšã¯ãå ¬æš©åãšåžæ°ã®åæ¹ããæš©åã®æ¿«çšãææ¢ãããå¶åºŠã«ãã£ãŠé©çšããããå ¬éãããäžè¬çã§ãäºæž¬å¯èœãªã«ãŒã«ã«åŸå±ããŠãããšããååã§ããã
ãã®äžå¿çãªåãã¯ãåçŽã ããçããã®ã¯å®¹æã§ã¯ãªããããªãã¡ãæ³ã¯çµ±æ²»è ãå¶éããããã«æ©èœããŠããã®ãããããšãæš©åããã§ã«è¡ããšæ±ºããäºæã«æ³çãªå€èгãäžããããã ãã«çšããããŠããã®ãããšããåãã§ããã
æ¿åºã¯èŠç¯ã坿±ºããæ¿ä»€ãçºåžããæåŸãèŠæ±ããããšãã§ãããããããç¹å®ã®äººãåŠçœ°ããããå¥ã®äººãåªéãããããããã¯ããããå®å¹çãªé²åŸ¡ãé»ãããã«ã«ãŒã«ã倿Žã§ããã®ã§ããã°ãæ³åŸãååšããã ãã§ã¯èªç±ãä¿è·ããã®ã«ååã§ã¯ãªãã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ æš©åè ããŸãçŸå®ã®æ³çãªéçã«çŽé¢ããåžæ°ããã®éçãæ³çã«äž»åŒµã»è¡äœ¿ã§ãããšããæ³ã®åªäœãååšããã
æ³ã®åªäœãæå³ãããã®
ãã®è¡šçŸã¯ã瀟äŒãæžé¢åããããããªãåœä»€ã«ãç²ç®çã«åŸããªããã°ãªããªãããšãæå³ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããã¯ãæš©åãæ¢ç¥ã®æš©éãšæç¶ãã®ç¯å²å ã§ãåå¥ã®äºäŸã«ãããèªãã®éœåã«å·Šå³ãããªãã«ãŒã«ã®ããšã§è¡åããããšãæå³ããŠããã
åœéé£åã«ããå®çŸ©ã¯ãåœå®¶ãå ¬ã«å ¬åžãããå¹³çãã€ç¬ç«ããŠå·è¡ãããæ³åŸã«åŸå±ããããšããŸãã«åŒ·èª¿ããŠããããã®ç¹ã¯åãªã圢åŒçãªé£Ÿãã§ã¯ãªããæ¯é è ãã«ãŒã«ã®å€åŽã«èªãã眮ãããšãã§ãããªãã諞暩å©ã¯åãæ¶ãå¯èœãªæ©æµãžãšå€ããã®ã§ããã
A. V. Diceyã«ããå€å žçãªå®åŒåã«ãããŠããã®æŠå¿µãçè§£ããäžã§ç¹ã«æçãª2ã€ã®åŽé¢ããããããã¯ãæ£æçãªæš©åã«å¯Ÿããæ³ã®åªäœãšãéåžžæ³ã®äžã§ã®äžäººã®å¹³çã§ãããçŸä»£ã®æ²æ³çè«ã¯ãã®åæãæ¡åŒµããŠãããããã®åºæ¬çãªçæ³ã¯äŸç¶ãšããŠæ žå¿ã«ããç¶ããŠããã
ãã®ãããæ³ã®åªäœã¯å ·äœçãªæ¡ä»¶ã«ãã£ãŠèªèãããã
- èŠç¯ã¯ã人ãããã«åŸããªããã°ãªããªããªãåã«ãå ¬ã«ç¥ãããçè§£å¯èœã§ããããšã
- ã«ãŒã«ã¯äžè¬æ§ãæã£ãŠçå®ãããç¹å®ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ã«åãããåŠçœ°ãç¹æš©ãšããŠäœãããªãããšã
- æ³ã®æ¹å€ã¯åççãªå®å®æ§ãä¿ã¡ãåžæ°ãé¡åçã«äžææã¡ããªãããšã
- æš©åã¯èªãã®æ±ºå®ã«ã€ããŠçç±ã説æããªããã°ãªãããæç¢ºã«å®çŸ©ãããæš©éã®ç¯å²å ã§è¡åããããšã
- 圱é¿ãåããè ã¯ãç¬ç«ãã€å ¬å¹³ãªåžæ³ã«ææžãæ±ããããšãã§ããããšã
ãããã®æ¡ä»¶ã¯ãããããæ³åŸãè³¢æã§ããããšãããããã蚎èšãæ£ããçµçµããããšãçŽæãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããããã¯ãããæ ¹æ¬çãªãã®ãããªãã¡æš©åã«å¯ŸããŠç°è°ãå±ããå審æ»ãæ±ãããããå¶éããããšãå¯èœãªæ çµã¿ãçã¿åºãã®ã§ããã
æ³åŸãæã€ããšãšæ³åŸã«ãã£ãŠå¶éãããããšã¯å矩ã§ã¯ãªã
åæ³æ§ã¯éèŠã§ãããèŠç¯çæ ¹æ ãªãã«è¡åããåœå±ã¯ããã§ã«æçœãªåé¡ãæèµ·ããŠãããããããèŠç¯ã«åºã¥ããŠè¡åããŠããããšèªäœã¯ãã誰ããã®èŠç¯ã®å 容ãé©çšãéçãçµ±å¶ããã®ãããšããäž»èŠãªåãã«åç¬ã§çãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
ããè¡æ¿åœå±ã鿥ã«å¶æ¥èš±å¯ã矩åä»ããŠãããšæ³å®ããŠã¿ããã客芳çãªåºæºãæéãçç±èª¬æãããã³åžæ³çææžææ®µã䌎ãå ¬éãããã«ãŒã«ã§ããã°ãè©äŸ¡ãããå¿ èŠã«å¿ããŠç°è°ãç³ãç«ãŠãããšãã§ãããããã«å¯Ÿããåãèš±å¯ã峿¹ã«ã¯äžããæ¹å€è ã«ã¯èª¬æããªãæåŠããåœå±ã¯ããã®æç¶ããæ¿æ²»çéžå¥ã®ææ®µãšããŠå©çšããŠããã®ã§ããã
ãã®éãã¯ãããæ±ºå®ã«å ¬çãªå°ãæŒãããŠããŠãå¥ã®æ±ºå®ã«ã¯æŒãããŠããªããšããç¹ã«ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããéãã¯ãåžæ°ãå ±éã®ã«ãŒã«ã«çŽé¢ããŠããã®ãããããšãåã ã®åœ¹äººã®åå¥çãªæåã«äŸåããŠããã®ããšããç¹ã«ããã
æ³ã®æ¯é ãšã®é¢ä¿
ã¹ãã€ã³èªã«ãããŠããæ³ã®åªäœããšãæ³ã®æ¯é ãã¯è¿ãæŠå¿µãšããŠäœ¿ãããããšãå€ããç¹å®ã®æèã§ã¯åãè±èªè¡šçŸã§ãããrule of lawãã®èš³èªãšããŠçšããããããšããããããããããããæ³çãªè°è«ã«ãããŠãäž¡è ãå®å šãªå矩èªãšããŠæ±ããªãããšãæãŸããã
æ³ã®æ¯é ã¯ãããåºç¯ãªå¶åºŠçç§©åºãããªãã¡æš©ååç«ãåžæ³ã«ããææžãåºæ¬ç人暩ããããŠæ²æ³äžã®çµ±å¶ãæããããããã«å¯ŸããŠæ³ã®åªäœã¯ããã®ç§©åºã貫ãäžã€ã®èŠè«ãããªãã¡æš©åãè¡äœ¿ããè ãã«ãŒã«ã«åŸå±ããæ°ãŸããã«ãã£ãŠçµ±æ²»ããŠã¯ãªããªããšããç¹ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãã
å®è·µã«ãããŠäœãèŠæ±ããã®ã
ãŽã§ããã£ã¢å§å¡äŒã¯ããã®ååã«é¢ããçŸä»£ã®è©äŸ¡åºæºããåæ³æ§ãæ³çå®å®æ§ãæš©åæ¿«çšã®é²æ¢ãæ³ã®äžã®å¹³çããããŠåžæ³ãžã®ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ãäžå¿ã«äœç³»åããŠãããæ¥åžžã®ç掻ã«åŒãçŽããŠèããã°ãããã¯å°éå®¶ã®ããã®ãªã¹ãã§ã¯ãªããå人ã®äººçãäžå€ãããããªã決å®ã«å¯Ÿããé²å£ãªã®ã§ããã
åšç¥ãããåççã«å®å®ããã«ãŒã«
人ã¯ãèªèº«ã«äœãæåŸ ãããŠããã®ããç¥ã£ãŠåããŠãèªãã®è¡åãæ¹åã¥ããããšãã§ãããç§å¯ã«ãããææ§ã§ãéµå®ãäžå¯èœã§ãã£ããããããã¯é¡åçã«é©çšããããããèŠç¯ã¯ãè¡åã®æéãšã¯ãªããªããããã¯åžæ°ãåœå±ã®äºåŸçãªå€æã«ç¡é²åã«æãã ãã§ããã
ãã®ãããªäºæž¬å¯èœæ§ããã£ãŠãããå¥çŽãçµã¶ããäºæ¥ãç«ã¡äžããããäœå± ãåããããæèŠãå ¬è¡šããããæš©å©ã䞻匵ããããæ±ºæããããšãå¯èœã«ãªããæ³çå®å®æ§ã¯èªç±ã®å®è·µçæ¡ä»¶ã§ããããªããªããããã¯å¶è£æš©åãæ¡ãè ã«å¯ŸããŠéå ¬åŒãªèš±å¯ãæ±ããã«è¡åããããšãå¯èœã«ããããã§ããã
æ³ã®äžã®å¹³ç
äžè¬åžæ°ã«ã¯å³ããã«ãŒã«ã課ãããæš©åãã³ããæã€è ã«ã¯äºå®äžã®äŸå€ãèªããããããã§ããã°ããã®ååã¯ãã®æå³ã倱ããæ³ã®äžã®å¹³çã¯ãå ¬è·ãæ¿æ²»çè¿ããçç±ã«ãäœè ãæ³ã®äžã«ç«ã€ããšããããã¯æ³ã®ä¿è·ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ããå€ãããããšããã£ãŠã¯ãªããªããšèŠæ±ããã
æ³çãªå¹³çã¯ããã¹ãŠã®äººãåãç©è³ªççµæãåŸããããšäž»åŒµãããã®ã§ããªããããã¯ããã以åã®äºæãããªãã¡åŒ·å¶åãæã€æš©åã®åã§ã¯ã察象ãšãªã人ç©ã®çŽ æ§ã«ãã£ãŠã«ãŒã«ãä¿èšŒãå€ãã£ãŠã¯ãªããªããšããç¹ã䞻匵ããŠããã®ã§ããã
驿£æç¶ããšç¬ç«ããè£å€å®
åœå±ãåœäºè ã®èšãåãèãããšãªãå¶è£ãç§ãããšãã§ãããããã®åŠåã審æ»ããè£å€æãåŠåãåºããåœã®åœ¹äººã«è¿œåŸããŠããããããªãã°ãææåãããå¶éãªã©è匱ãªãã®ã«ãããªãã
å ¬çãªæ±ºå®ãèªç±ã財ç£ãæš©å©ã«åœ±é¿ãäžãããå Žåãåžæ°ã¯ãã®çç±ãç¥ããåŒæãè¡ããå ¬å¹³ãªå審æ»ãåããå¿ èŠããããåžæ³ã®ç¬ç«ã¯è£å€å®ãç¡è¬¬ã«ããããã§ã¯ãªããããã¯ãæš©åããããããã³ã³ãããŒã«ã§ããªãæ³çãªå€æãåããããšãå¯èœã«ããã®ã§ããã
ãªãèªç±ãªç€ŸäŒãå®ãã®ã
å€å žçèªç±äž»çŸ©ã®äŒçµ±ã«ãããŠãæ³ã®åªäœã®äŸ¡å€ã¯è¡æ¿çãªç§©åºã«ãšã©ãŸããªãããã®æ©èœã¯ãå人ã®èªç±ã統治è ã®æ©æµã人éé¢ä¿ããããã¯äžæçãªå¯å®¹ã«äŸåããããšãé²ãç¹ã«ããã
ãã®çµã³ã€ãã¯æ¥åžžçãªæŽ»åã®äžã«èŠãããšãã§ããã
- æèŠã衚æããè ã¯ãçºèšããåŸã«æ¥é ãããã«ãŒã«ã«ãã£ãŠåŠçœ°ãããªãããšãç¥ã£ãŠããå¿ èŠãããã
- äœå± ãåºèãææããè ã¯ãèªãã®ç§æè²¡ç£ã«å¯Ÿããæ£æçãªäŸµå®³ã«å¯ŸããŠãæç¶ããšé²åŸ¡ã®ææ®µãå¿ èŠãšããã
- å¥çŽãçµã¶è ã¯ãåœäºè ã®äžæ¹ã«åœ±é¿åãããå Žåã§ãã£ãŠããå ±éã®ã«ãŒã«ãé©çšããè£å€æãå¿ èŠãšããã
- èµ·æ¥ããè ã¯ãèŠå¶åœå±è ãšã®å人çãªé§ãåŒãã§ã¯ãªããèš±èªå¯ãå¶è£ã«é¢ããå ¬çãªåºæºãå¿ èŠãšããã
World Justice Projectã¯ãæ³ã«åŸå±ããç§©åºã®ç¹åŸŽãšããŠãæç¢ºã§ãå ¬éãããå®å®ããŠãããäžæ§ã«é©çšãããèŠç¯ãšãšãã«ã財ç£ãå¥çŽãããã³èšŽèšæç¶ãäžã®æš©å©ã®ä¿è·ãæããŠããããã®é¢ä¿ã¯æ éã«çè§£ãããå¿ èŠãããããã®ååã¯ããã¹ãŠã®æè³ãæåããããšãããã¹ãŠã®çŽäºãæ¶æ» ããããšãä¿èšŒãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããã¯ãæš©åãæã®ãŸãŸã«å€æŽã§ããªãã«ãŒã«ã®äžã§ãèšç»ãç«ãŠãèªããå®ãå¯èœæ§ãä¿è·ããã®ã§ããã
財ç£ãåŽåãçµç€Ÿããããã¯äº€æã«é¢ããæ±ºå®ãå ¬çãªæ©æµã«äŸåããããã«ãªããšãåžæ°ã¯èªãã®çæŽ»ãææãæš©åãžã®è¿ãã«åãããŠèª¿æŽããããã«ãªããæ€èšŒå¯èœãªéçãååšãããšããåžæ°ã¯ãã倧ããªèªåŸæ§ããã£ãŠè¡åããèªãã®æ±ºå®ã«å¯ŸããŠè²¬ä»»ãè² ãããšãã§ããã®ã§ããã
è£éãšæ£æã¯åäžã§ã¯ãªã
è¿ä»£åœå®¶ã¯ããããªãè¡æ¿ç倿ã®äœå°ããªãã«æ©èœããããšã¯ã§ããªããæ€æ»å®ã¯äºå®ãè©äŸ¡ããªããã°ãªãããè£å€å®ã¯åå¥ã®äºæ¡ã«èŠç¯ãé©çšããªããã°ãªãããåœå±ã¯æ³çãªæš©éã®ç¯å²å ã§è³æºã®åªå é äœã決ããªããã°ãªããªãå Žåãããã
è£éã¯ãæš©éãå ¬çãªåºæºãçç±èª¬æã®çŸ©åãããã³å¯©æ»ã®ä»çµã¿ã«ãã£ãŠç»å®ãããŠãããšããæ³ã®åªäœãšäž¡ç«ãããããã¯ãåæ ãæµæãè³è³ããããã¯å 掟çãªäŸ¿å®ã«ãã£ãŠæ±ºå®ãäžãããšã蚱容ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
åœå®¶ã®æ£æã¯ãããããéçãæ¬ åŠããŠããããç¡ååããŠãããšãã«çŸãããããªãã¡ãæ¢ç¥ã®åºæºãååšãããçæ¯ãªèª¬æããªããããç¬ç«ããææžçãååšããªããããããã¯åäžã®ã«ãŒã«ãéžæçã«é©çšãããå Žåã§ããã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ æ£ææ§ãå¶éããããšã¯ãããããå ¬çæ±ºå®ã麻çºãããããšãèŠæ±ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããæš©åããã®æ±ºå®ãã«ãŒã«ã«ãã£ãŠæ£åœåããå®å¹çãªçµ±å¶ã«çŽé¢ãããããšãèŠæ±ããã®ã§ããã
æ³ã®åªäœã¯ã©ã®ããã«æãªãããã
ãã®ååã®äŸµå®³ã¯ãå¿ ãããç¡å¶éã®æš©åãå ¬ç¶ãšå®£èšãã圢ã§çãããšã¯éããªããããã¯ãã°ãã°ãåžæ°ã®ä¿è·ã空æŽåãããªããããå€èŠäžã®åæ³æ§ãä¿ã£ãæ £è¡ãéããŠé²è¡ããã
ããã€ãã®æç¢ºãªå åãšããŠã次ã®ãããªãã®ãæããããã
- ç¹å®ã®å人ãéå£ã害ããããã«èšèšãããæ³åŸãå¶è£ã
- è¡åããæç¹ã§ã¯èš±å¯ãããŠããããšããé¡åçã«åŠçœ°å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãããã³ã¹ããè² ããããããèŠç¯ã
- éžæçã«é©çšãããäŸå€ãç¹æš©ã
- 審æ»å¯èœãªçç±ã䌎ããªãããããã¯åœ¢åŒçãªææžææ®µãã䌎ããªãè¡æ¿æ±ºå®ã
- æ¿åºãçµ±å¶ããããšã劚ããæ¿æ²»çå§åãåããŠããè£å€æã
- ã«ãŒã«ãéµå®ãã代ããã«äŸ¿å®ãæ±ããããåŸãªãããããçµ¶ãéãªã倿Žãäžéæãªå€æŽã
äžè¬çãªæ³åŸã§ãã£ãŠãäžæ£çŸ©ã§ããããšã¯ããããããã®ååããèªäœã ãã§ãæš©å©ãæ£çŸ©ããããã¯å ¬å ±æ¿çã®é©åãªç¯å²ãããããã¹ãŠã®è°è«ã解決ãããããã§ã¯ãªããããããå ¬éæ§ãäžè¬æ§ãå¹³çããããŠåžæ³ã«ããçµ±å¶ããªããã°ãããããè°è«ããè åšã®äžã§è¡ãããããšã«ãªããæš©åã¯å®å¹çãªå¶éãªãã«æåŸã®æ±ºå®æš©ãä¿æãç¶ããããã§ããã
æš©åã®å¶éãšããŠã®æ³
æ³ã®åªäœã¯ãæ¿æ²»ççã«ãããæ ¹æ¬çãªåãã«çãããã®ã§ãããããªãã¡ãæš©åã人ã ãèªãã®ç®çã®ããã®ææ®µãšããŠæ±ã£ãããèªãã®æ©æµã«äŸåããããããããšãããã«ããŠé²ããããšããåãã§ããã
ãã®çãã¯ãç¹ã«æåŸ³ãªçµ±æ²»è ã«äŸæ ããããšã«ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããã¯ãå ¬éãããäžè¬çãªèŠç¯ãããã«åŸå±ããåœå±ãæ³çãªå¹³çããããŠæš©åããã®éçãèžã¿è¶ãããšãã«åžæ°ãä¿è·ãããè£å€å®ãèŠæ±ããããšã«ããã
èªç±ãªç€ŸäŒã¯æ³åŸãå¿ èŠãšããããããäœãããããããã®æ³åŸãç¹æš©çãªæå¿ã®å¶åšã§ã¯ãªããå人ãåççãªå®å¿ããã£ãŠçããæ±ºæããå¥çŽããææããç°è°ãå±ããããšãå¯èœã«ããéçã§ããããšãå¿ èŠãšããŠããã®ã§ããã
åèæç®
- åœéé£åãæ³ã®æ¯é ãšã¯äœãïŒãã
- ãŽã§ããã£ã¢å§å¡äŒãRule of Law ChecklistãïŒ2016幎ïŒã
- Jeremy WaldronãThe Rule of LawãStanford Encyclopedia of Philosophyã
- A. V. DiceyãIntroduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitutionã第2éšç¬¬4ç« ã
- World Justice ProjectãWhat is the Rule of Law?ãã
å ±æ