Digital Autonomy: What It Is and What It Depends On

Digital autonomy is the practical ability to make decisions and act in digital environments according to your own goals. It takes skills, viable options, and the ability to reconsider your choices.

By Daniel Sardá · Published on

6 min read1,212 words

In this article · 5 sections

Digital autonomy is the practical ability a person has to make decisions and act in digital environments according to their own goals. Knowing how to use an app contributes to that freedom, but so do understanding its terms, having alternatives, and being able to reconsider a decision.

Imagine storing your documents with a cloud service. You know how to create folders and share files. But if you wanted to move them to another service, could you do so without losing information you need? The difference between operating a tool and being able to decide how you use it helps explain the concept.

The term has several uses, from education to debates about technological dependence. Here we consider it from the individual's perspective: what a person can decide, with what information, and under what constraints.

Using a tool and being able to choose

Digital competence includes the knowledge, skills, and attitudes needed to engage with technology critically and responsibly. The European institutional framework DigComp includes evaluating information, protecting privacy, and solving problems. It goes far beyond learning where to click.

These abilities help people exercise autonomy: they make it possible to understand a choice and put it into practice. Even so, a highly competent person may face external constraints, such as a service that is difficult to leave, an inadequate internet connection, or alternatives that do not meet their needs.

Faure, Vendramin, and Schurmans propose a situated approach to digital exclusion that understands autonomy as room to maneuver in the face of prescribed digital practices. This perspective asks what a person can do in their particular circumstances, without reducing the answer to how much they know about technology.

Autonomy therefore comes in degrees and depends on the situation. Someone may be comfortable deciding how to organize their files yet need guidance to understand who has permission to access those same documents.

Key idea: Digital autonomy depends both on what you know how to do and on the conditions that let you turn a decision into action.

The conditions that make a decision viable

Access is a starting point. Having devices and an internet connection shapes the possibilities for participation. DigComp also recognizes guidance and assistance among the conditions that can help people develop basic digital competences.

Then there is understanding: knowing what a tool is used for, what information it requires, and the relevant consequences of accepting it. A choice can hardly express a person's own goals if they do not understand what they are deciding.

Alternatives matter too. A selection of different names offers little if the available options are inaccessible, incompatible with an essential need, or too expensive. From the perspective of individual liberty, what matters is the effective ability to choose and reconsider that choice.

Returning to the storage example, moving to another service would involve three questions:

  • Recovering the files: Can you obtain the documents you want to keep?
  • Using them in the new service: Will their formats and organization still be useful?
  • Managing the transition: What time, learning, expense, and security precautions will the move require?

These are conditions in a hypothetical example; actual features depend on the service. Knowing how to download a file would solve part of the problem. You would still need to check what happens to the information as a whole and how much work is involved in moving everything.

OECD research on data portability indicates that transferring data can reduce the costs of changing providers, although the effects depend on how the data can be transferred and reused. It also recognizes potential privacy and security risks. Data portability can expand options, but its usefulness depends on examining those conditions.

Getting help can expand autonomy

Asking for guidance does not mean giving up the ability to decide. A clear explanation can enable someone to evaluate an option they did not understand before. Assistance can also help them carry out their own decision.

The relevant distinction arises when help replaces the person's participation. Explaining the consequences of moving documents and providing support through the process can expand their room to act. Deciding for them what to keep or where to store it, without consulting them, takes their place in decisions that concern them.

Autonomy does not require absolute independence: what matters is being able to participate in relevant decisions in an informed way. Requiring everyone to solve every technical issue alone would exclude forms of support that can expand their ability to act.

Key idea: Support is compatible with autonomy when it helps people understand, decide, and act according to their own goals.

Privacy and sovereignty: related concepts

Privacy affects an important dimension of autonomy: what information about us is exposed and under what conditions. Personal data control offers a way to examine that relationship.

But strong protection for information does not by itself resolve every difficulty involving access, understanding, or choice. A person could have privacy safeguards and still not understand how to retrieve their documents. Evaluating their autonomy requires looking at those other conditions too.

Digital sovereignty raises another question: who seeks to decide, and over what? In institutional debates, it can refer to the ability of a state or political community to direct its technological choices. For example, the European Commission discusses it in terms of the European Union's strategic independence. The term is also used in a personal context.

It is therefore useful to specify who is exercising sovereignty. Greater control over infrastructure by an authority does not, by itself, establish that each person has more freedom to choose services or protect their information. These questions require separate assessments.

From the liberal perspective guiding this article, the question is how public and private decisions affect individuals' ability to choose, dissent, and change course. The origin of a technology alone does not answer those questions.

Choosing a dependence and being able to reconsider it

Using services provided by others means entrusting part of an activity to them. That delegation can be reasonable for reasons of convenience, cost, security, or quality. Voluntary dependence is not, in itself, coercion, nor does it eliminate all autonomy.

In the storage example, one person might consider the difficulties of moving and decide to stay. That decision may reflect their priorities. Another might accept the effort of changing because they value a different feature or set of terms more highly.

What matters is how much each person understands, which alternatives they can use, and what obstacles they face if they change their mind. The aim of digital autonomy is to have enough room to direct one's relationship with technology, including the dependencies one chooses to accept.

Key idea: A chosen dependence can be reasonable. Assessing autonomy also means considering whether you can understand and reconsider it.

When evaluating your storage service, the useful question goes beyond whether you know how to use it: if your needs changed tomorrow, what could you decide, and what would you need to put that decision into practice? That is where your real room for digital autonomy becomes visible.

About the author

Daniel Sardá is an SEO Specialist, a university-level technician in Foreign Trade from Universidad Simón Bolívar, and editor of Libertatis Venezuela. He writes on liberalism, political economy, institutions, propaganda and individual liberty from an independent, non-partisan perspective.

Read full profile