éçããå€å 䞻矩ãšã¯ãäºãã«çžå®¹ããªã宿çãé埳çãå²åŠçãªæèª¬ããèªç±ãã€å¹³çãªååšãšããŠååããææãæã€åžæ°ã«ãã£ãŠåæããæ¯æãããæ°žç¶çã«å ±çããŠããç¶æ ãæããJohn Rawls ã¯ãããå°é£ãªåãã«çããããã«ãã®æŠå¿µãå±éãããããªãã¡ãåžæ°ãåãçã«ã€ããŠã®åäžã®èŠ³å¿µãå ±æããŠããªããšããæ¿æ²»ç§©åºã¯ããã«ããŠæ£çµ±ã§ããããã®ãããšããåãã§ããã
ãã®çãã¯ãå·®ç°ãæ¶ãå»ãããšã§ããããããæèŠãçãã劥åœã§ãããšå®£èšããããšã§ããªããããã¯ãç°ãªãæ·±ãä¿¡å¿µãæ±ã人ã ããç¹å®ã®å€æ°æŽŸã®æèª¬ã«æåŸãããããããšãªãåãå ¥ãããããããªãååã®è«žæ¡ä»¶ãèŠåºãããšã«ããã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ èªç±ãªç€ŸäŒã¯é埳çãªå šäŒäžèŽãå¿ èŠãšããªããããããèªç±ãã€å¹³çãªåžæ°ã®éã§æ£åœåãããå ±éã®èŠåã¯å¿ èŠãšããã
ãªãæèŠã®çžéã¯åžžã«å€±æãæå³ããããã§ã¯ãªãã®ã
ååãªæ å ±ãšåæãããã°ãéçãã人ã ã¯æ¬è³ªçãªåé¡ã«ãããŠæçµçã«åæã«è³ãã¯ãã ãšèããã®ã¯é åçãããããªããRawls ã¯ãã®æåŸ ãéããã誰ãåãã€ãããäžèª å®ã«è¡åããŠããªããšãã蚌æ ã¯è€éã§ãããã諞䟡å€ã¯ç·åŒµé¢ä¿ã«é¥ãããšããããå人ã®çµéšã«ãã£ãŠéã¿ã¥ããç°ãªãçµæã«ãªãããããã§ããã
ããããå°é£ããã倿ã®è² æ ã§ãããåäžã®åé¡ãè©äŸ¡ããéãã©ã®èšŒæ ãæ±ºå®çã§ãããããã䟡å€ãå¥ã®äŸ¡å€ãšæ¯ã¹ãŠã©ãã»ã©ã®éã¿ãæã€ãããããã¯äžè¬çãªåçãå ·äœçãªäºäŸã«ã©ãé©çšãã¹ããã«ã€ããŠãäºäººã®äººéãæèŠãç°ã«ããããšããããå€ãã®é埳çã»æ¿æ²»çæŠå¿µã®ææ§ããããã®å°é£ããã£ããå¢å€§ãããã
ãããããæ ¹æ·±ã倿§æ§ã¯ãæè²ã鲿©ã«ãã£ãŠæ¶æ» ãããããªåãªãå¶ç¶ã®ç£ç©ãšã¯éããªãã人ã ã信念ãåå³ããçµç€Ÿãçµã³ãç°è«ã衚æã§ããèªç±ãªå¶åºŠã®ããšã§ã¯ãç°ãªãæèª¬ãçããåç¶ãç¶ããããšãäºæž¬ãããã®ã§ããã
ã ãããšãã£ãŠãããããç«å Žãéçã«ããªã£ãŠããããšã«ãªãããã§ã¯ãªããåèŠãæäœãååãè£ ã£ãèªå·±å©çããããã¯å¹³çãªèªç±ã®åŠå®ã¯ãåã«æèŠã®çžéãçã¿åºããŠãããšããäºå®ã ãã§æ£åœåããããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããã§ã®ãéçããããšã¯ãç©å¥ãäžéããããã¯ç¡è¬¬ã§ããããšãæå³ããªããããã¯ãä»è ãå¹³çãªååšãšããŠèªããä»è ããŸãåãå ¥ãããååã®æ¡ä»¶ãææ¡ãããšãããäžã€ã®æ¿æ²»çãªæ 床ã衚ããŠããã®ã§ããã
倿§æ§ã ãã§ã¯äžååïŒçžäºæ§ã決å®çã§ãã
ãã瀟äŒã¯ãéçããå€å ç瀟äŒã§ãªããšãå€å çã§ãããããç°ãªãéå£ãååšãããããã°ã瀟äŒã¯å€å çã«ãªãããããã§ãããéçããå€å 䞻矩ã¯ãããèŠæ±ãä»å ãããããªãã¡ãæèŠãç°ã«ãã人ã ã¯ãçžäºæ§ãšåºæ¬çèªç±ã®æ çµã¿ãåãå ¥ããªããã°ãªããªããšããããšã§ããã
ãã®çžäºæ§ã¯ããèªãã®æèª¬ãããççã§ãããããã«äžäººãããã«åŸããªããã°ãªããªãããšãã£ãè«çã§æ¿æ²»ç匷å¶åãæ£åœåããããšãçŠããããã確信ãäžäººã®äººéã®äººçãå®å šã«å°ããŠãããšããŠãããããå ±æããªã人ã ã«å¯ŸããŠè¡äœ¿ãããæš©åã®æ£åœåãšããŠã¯ãäžååãªå Žåãããã
ãã®éãã¯ç°¡åãªäŸãèŠãã°çè§£ã§ãããä¿¡ä»°ãæã€äººã¯ãè¯å¿ãç¥èãªãã®ãšã¿ãªããŠãããããã«ä¿¡æã®èªç±ãæè·ãããããããªãã仿¹ã§ãä¿¡ä»°ãæããªã人ã¯ãäœäººãä¿¡ä»°ã®åçœã匷å¶ãããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªããšããçç±ãããããæ¯æãããããããªããäž¡è ã¯ç©¶æ¥µçãªæ ¹æ ãå ±æããŠã¯ããªãããåäžã®å¶åºŠçä¿éãæ¯æããããšã¯ã§ããã®ã§ããã
æçãªåºå¥ïŒ åãªãå€å 䞻矩ã¯å·®ç°ãååšããããšã確èªãããéçããå€å 䞻矩ã¯ãäžæ¹ã®åŽã仿¹ãæ¯é ããããšãªãããããªãèŠåã®ããšã§ãããã®å·®ç°ãå ±åãããããåãã
å æ¬çæèª¬ãšæ¿æ²»çæ§æ³
Rawls ã¯ãäœãççã§ãããäœã«äŸ¡å€ããããããã«çããã®ãæ£ããéã§ãããã«é¢ããå æ¬çãªèŠè§£ãå æ¬çæèª¬ãšåŒã¶ã宿ãäžä¿çå²åŠããããã¯é埳çè«ããã®æ©èœãæãããããããããäžããçãã¯ãå ¬çå¶åºŠã®ç¯å²ãã¯ããã«è¶ãã人çã®æ¬¡å ã«ãŸã§åã¶ã
ããã«å¯ŸããŠãæ¿æ²»çæ§æ³ã¯ãããéå®ããã察象ãæã€ãããã¯ç€ŸäŒçãªååã®å ¬æ£ãªæ¡ä»¶ãå®ãã瀟äŒã®åºæ¬æ§é ãããªãã¡äž»èŠãªå¶åºŠãèªç±ããããŠæ£çŸ©ã®åºæºãæ¹åã¥ããããšãç®æãã人çã®æå³ã«é¢ããããããåãã解決ããããšãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
ãã®åºåãéèŠã§ããçç±ã¯ãå ±éã®æ¿æ²»çæ§æ³ãã人ã ã«èªãã®ä¿¡å¿µã®æŸæ£ãèŠæ±ããªãããã§ãããããã¯ããããªãå æ¬çæèª¬ããåœå®¶æš©åãéããŠæŒãã€ããããå ¬åŒã®é埳ãžãšåç¬ã§è»¢åããŠã¯ãªããªãããšãèŠæ±ããã
å人ã®èªç±ãéèŠãã芳ç¹ããèŠãã°ããã®èãæ¹ã¯éèŠãªä¿è·ãæäŸãããè¯å¿ã®èªç±ãäžè¬çãªèŠåããããŠæš©åã®å¶éãããããšã§ã倿§ãªå ±åäœã¯ãããããé埳çæèŠã®çžéãåœå®¶ã®æ¯é æš©ãå·¡ãéäºãžãšå€ããããšãªããèªãã®æ§æ³ãçºå±ãããããšãã§ããããã®ããšã¯ Rawls ãå€å žçèªç±äž»çŸ©è ã«ããããã§ã¯ãªãã圌ã®çè«ã®ãã¹ãŠãåãå ¥ããããšã匷ãããã®ã§ããªããããããäžã€ã®åæç¹ã瀺ããŠãããããªãã¡ã匷å¶ã«ã¯å¶éãå¿ èŠã§ãããåãªã倿°æŽŸã®æå¿ããã峿 Œãªæ£åœåãèŠæ±ããããšããç¹ã§ããã
éãªãåãåæïŒåäžã®åæ©ã«ãããªãåæ
ç°ãªãæèª¬ãããããã®ç¬èªã®çç±ã«åºã¥ããŠåäžã®æ¿æ²»çæ§æ³ãæ¯æãããšããRawls ãéãªãåãåæãšåŒã¶ãã®ãç«ã¡çŸãããåè¿°ã®äŸã«ãããä¿¡ä»°è ãšéä¿¡ä»°è ã¯ãç°ãªãéçããã©ã£ãŠãã®çµè«ã«éãããšããŠããä¿¡æã®èªç±ãä¿è·ãããšããç¹ã«ãããŠäžèŽããŠããã
ãã®åæã¯å šäŒäžèŽã§ã¯ãªãã人ã ã¯äŸç¶ãšããŠå®æãé埳ããããŠå€ãã®å ¬å ±æ¿çã«ã€ããŠæèŠãç°ã«ãç¶ããããŸããåãªãã¢ãã¥ã¹ã»ãŽã£ãŽã§ã³ãã£ãããªãã¡ããããªãéå£ãèªãã®æå¿ãä»è ã«æŒãã€ããã ãã®ååãªåãæããªããšããçç±ã ãã§ç¶æãããŠããäŒæŠåå®ã§ããªããéãªãåãåæã«ãããŠã¯ãå ±éã®èŠåãžã®æ¯æãåéå£ã®ç¢ºä¿¡ã®äžéšã圢æããŠãããæ«å®çãªåé¢ä¿ã®åè¡¡ã®ã¿ã«äŸåããŠããããã§ã¯ãªãã®ã§ããã
ããããåæã®å¯èœæ§ã¯ããããå¿ ãçããããšãä¿èšŒãããã®ã§ããªããæš©åã®äžå¹³çãäžä¿¡æããããŠçžäºæ§ãæçµ¶ããæèª¬ã®ååšããããã劚ããããšããããããã¯å®å®æ§ãšæ£çµ±æ§ã«é¢ããç念ã§ãã£ãŠãããããæ°äž»äž»çŸ©ã«é¢ããèªåçãªäºæž¬ã§ã¯ãªãã
å ¬å ±ççæ§ãèŠæ±ãããã®
å ¬å ±ççæ§ãããã®æ çµã¿ãå®çµããããæ²æ³äžã®æ¬è³ªçèŠçŽ ãæ£çŸ©ã®åºæ¬çäºé ãåé¡ãšãªãå Žåãæ¿æ²»æš©åãè¡äœ¿ããè ã¯ãããšãä»è ãèªãã®å æ¬çæèª¬ãå ±æããŠããªããšããä»ã®åžæ°ãæ¿æ²»çãªçç±ãšããŠæ¿èªãããçç±ãæç€ºããªããã°ãªããªãã
ããã¯ä¿¡ä»°ãå²åŠããããã¯é埳çäŒçµ±ã®ç«å ŽããèªãããšãçŠãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããŸããããããç§çãªäŒè©±ãèŠå¶ãããè°è«ã«å€ããŠããŸããã®ã§ããªããæ¹èšãããå®åŒåã«ãããŠãRawls ã¯ããããã¹ãææã«å ±éã®æ±ºå®ãæ£åœåããã®ã«ååãªæ¿æ²»ççç±ãæç€ºãããéãã«ãããŠãå ¬çãªè°è«ã«å æ¬ççç±ãæã¡èŸŒãããšãèªããŠããã
ãã®èŠæ±ã¯ããšããã匷å¶åã®è¡äœ¿ã«åããããŠãããèªçºçãªçµç€Ÿã§ããã°ãã¯ããã«å ·äœçãªè²¬åãä¿¡æ¡ãäžå¿ã«ããŠçµç¹ãããããããããäžäººã®åã«ãããŠæ³ãå¶å®ãå¶è£ãç§ãåœå®¶ã¯ããããšã¯ç°ãªãåºæºã«å¿ããªããã°ãªããªãã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ ãã信念ãå¯å®¹ã«æ±ãããšã¯ãã®ååšã蚱容ããããšã§ãããããããèŠç¯ãæ¿æ²»çã«æ£åœåããããã«ã¯ããã®ä¿¡å¿µãå ±æããªãè ã«å¯ŸããŠããªãããã課ãããšãã§ããã®ãã説æããªããã°ãªããªãã
éçããå€å 䞻矩ãæå³ããªããã®
ãã®æŠå¿µã¯ã倿§æ§ãå¯å®¹ã®å矩èªãšãªã£ãŠããŸããšããã®æç¢ºãã倱ããã¡ã§ãããããã§äžã€ã®å¢çç·ãåŒããŠããããšãæçã§ããã
第äžã«ãçžå¯Ÿäž»çŸ©ã§ã¯ãªããéçããåžæ°ãç°ãªãçµè«ã«éããããšãèªããããšã¯ããã¹ãŠã®èŠ³å¿µãçå®ã§ãããšãå容å¯èœã§ãããšè¯å®ããããšãæå³ããªãããã®æ çµã¿èªäœãå®è³ªçãªè«žäŸ¡å€ãããªãã¡èªç±ãå¹³çãçžäºæ§ããããŠååã®å ¬æ£ãªæ¡ä»¶ãå«ãã§ããã®ã§ããã
第äºã«ã絶察çäžç«æ§ãèŠæ±ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããåºæ¬çèªç±ãä¿è·ãå·®å¥ãæçµ¶ãã諞å¶åºŠã¯ãèªç±ãšæ¯é ã®éã§äžç«ã§ããããã§ã¯ãªãããããã®å¶åºŠãç®æãã®ã¯ãæ¿æ²»ç§©åºãæ£åœåããã«ããã£ãŠãåãçã«ã€ããŠã®å šäœçãªæ§æ³ã«äŸåããªãããšã§ããã
第äžã«ãçŽäºãæ¶ãå»ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããå ±æãããæ çµã¿ã®å éšã«ãããŠãããæš©å©ã®è§£éãå ¬çãªåªå äºé ããããŠåçã®é©çšãå·¡ãæèŠã®äžäžèŽã¯äŸç¶ãšããŠååšãããéçããå€å 䞻矩ã¯ããããã察ç«ãèŠåŸã¥ãããã®ã§ãããæ¶æ» ãããããã§ã¯ãªãã
ãŸãã倿åäž»çŸ©ãšæ··åãããŠããªããªãã倿å䞻矩ã¯éåžžãéå£ãã¢ã€ãã³ãã£ãã£ããããã¯æåçæ £ç¿ã®æ¿èªãæ±ããRawls çãªæŠå¿µã¯ãå¥ã®åé¡ãããªãã¡ç°ãªãå æ¬çæèª¬ãä¿¡å¥ããåžæ°éã«ãããå ±éèŠåã®æ£çµ±æ§ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠããå¶åºŠç倿§æ§ã«é¢ããããåºãæ çµã¿ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãæ¿æ²»çå€å 䞻矩ãåç §ããããã
æš©å©ãšå€æ°æŽŸã«å¯Ÿããéç
éçããæèŠã®çžéãèªç±ã®æ£åžžãªæ¡ä»¶ã§ãããªãã°ãéžæã«ãã倿°æŽŸããã®ããšã«ãã£ãŠç¡å¶éã®æš©åšãç²åŸããããã§ã¯ãªããåºæ¬çèªç±ã¯ãå人ãèªãã®ç¢ºä¿¡ã圢æããèŠçŽããããã«åŸã£ãŠçããããšãã§ããé åãä¿è·ããããŸãã倿°æŽŸããã®æ°çåªäœãå°æ°æŽŸã®æä¹ çãªé·å±ãžãšè»¢åãããããšãé»ãã
ãã®çµè«ã¯ãåã«å¯å®¹ãšæš©å©ãæ±ããããšãè¶ ããŠãããåã«å¯å®¹ã§ããã«ãšã©ãŸãè ã¯ãæ°ãå€ããã°ãã®å·®ç°ãæå§ããããšãã§ãããããããªããšããèããä¿æãç¶ãããããã«å¯ŸããŠæš©å©ã®ç§©åºã¯ãäžæçãªå€æ°æŽŸã®æã®ãŸãŸã«ã¯ãªããªãé åãæ¿èªããã
ãã®ããã«ããŠãéçããå€å 䞻矩ã¯ãæ°äž»äž»çŸ©ãåãªã祚ã®åå®ã«éå ãããªãçç±ã説æããã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã€ã倿°æ±ºã«ããæ±ºå®ã¯å€ãã®åé¡ã解決ããããã«å¿ èŠãªæç¶ãã§ããããããã¯åžæ°ãèªç±ãã€å¹³çã§ãããšããæ¡ä»¶ãä¿å šããå¶éã®ç¯å²å ã§æ©èœããã®ã§ããã
çŸå®ã®ç°è«ã䌎ããæçšãªæŠå¿µ
ãéçæ§ããšããåºæºã¯ãæ¿æ²»çã«ç¡å®³ãªãã®ã§ã¯ãªããæ¹å€è ã®äžäººã§ãã Chantal Mouffe ã¯ãéçããç«å Žãšéçã«åããªãç«å Žãšã®éã«å¢çç·ãåŒãããšã¯ãæé€ãé èœããäŸç¶ãšããŠä¿äºäžã§ããç§©åºãããããäžç«ã§ãããã®ããã«æç€ºããããšã«ãªããããªããšç°è°ãå±ããããã®æ¹å€ã¯ã誰ãå容å¯èœãªæ¡ä»¶ãå®çŸ©ããã®ãããããŠãããªã察ç«ãæ çµã¿ã®å€ã«çœ®ãããŠããŸãã®ããåãããšãè¿«ãã
ãŸãããã®çè«ãåžæ°ãå¶åºŠãçæ³åããŠãããšæ¹å€ããããšãã§ããã倧ããªé察称æ§ã«è²«ããã瀟äŒã«ãããŠã¯ãçžäºçãªçç±ãæ±ããã ãã§ã¯ã圱é¿åãåãŒããçµç¹åããçºèšã«è³ãåŸããŠãããèœåã®äžå¹³çãæ¯æ£ããã«ã¯äžååã§ãããããã«ãå ¬å ±ççæ§ãç¹å®ã®è«æ ã«éå®ããããšã¯ã硬çŽçã«é©çšãããå Žåãè°è«ã貧匱ã«ããŠããŸãæããããã
ãããã®ç°è«ã¯ããã®æŠå¿µãç¡çšã«ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããããã¯ãããããæ°äž»äž»çŸ©ã®å¿ å®ãªæåãšããŠã§ãããã¹ãŠã®æµå¯Ÿé¢ä¿ãç¡ååã§ããåŠæ¹ç®ãšããŠã§ããªããæš©åã®æ£çµ±æ§ãè©äŸ¡ããããã®åºæºãšããŠãæ éã«çšããå©ããšãªãã®ã§ããã
ç»äžåããããšãªãå ±ç
éçããå€å 䞻矩ã¯ãããéããäºå®èªèããåºçºãããããªãã¡ãèªç±ã¯æèŠã®çžéãçã¿åºãããããã¯åžžã«ããå€ãã®æ å ±ãããè¯ãæå³ã«ãã£ãŠè§£æ±ºã§ãããšã¯éããªãããšããããšã§ãããæ¿æ²»çå¿çã¯ãå ¬åŒã®æèª¬ãæŒãã€ããããšã§ãããã¹ãŠã®å·®ç°ãéèŠæ§ãæããªããã®ããã«è£ ãããšã§ããã£ãŠã¯ãªããªãã
ããã«ä»£ããéã¯ãããå€ãã®ãã®ãèŠæ±ãããããã¯ãåºæ¬çèªç±ãä¿è·ãã匷å¶ãå¶éãã察çãªè ã®éã§æ£åœåãããèŠåãç¶æããããšã«ããã人ã ã¯èªãã®ç¢ºä¿¡ãšç©¶æ¥µã®åæ©ãä¿æãç¶ãããå ±éããŠããã®ã¯ãäºããä»è ã®è£æ°ãšãªãããšãªãæèŠãç°ã«ãç¶ããããšãå¯èœã«ããæ¿æ²»çæ çµã¿ãªã®ã§ããã
äž»èŠåèæç®
- John Rawls, Political Liberalism, å¢è£ç, 1996.
- John Rawls, âThe Idea of Public Reason Revisitedâ, 1997.
- Samuel Freeman, âJohn Rawlsâ, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- Fred D'Agostino, Gerald Gaus, John Thrasher, âPublic Reasonâ, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- Chantal Mouffe, âThe Limits of John Rawls's Pluralismâ, 2005.
å ±æ