ãã人ç©ãäœå¹Žéãäžè»ã®å®¶ã«äœã¿ããããç¶æç®¡çããããããèªãã®å®¶ã§ãããã®ããã«å ¬ç¶ãšæ¯ãèã£ãŠãããšãããããã¯ãã®äººç©ãææè ã«ããã®ã ããããçµè«ããèšãã°ãå¿ ãããããã§ã¯ãªããããç©ã䜿çšããç©ççã«ææãããããã¯ç®¡çããŠããããšã ãã§ã¯ããã®ææè ã§ããããšãšå矩ã«ã¯ãªããªããããããªãããäžéšã®æ³äœç³»ã§ã¯ãæç¢ºãªèŠä»¶ã®äžã§ç¶æãããå æããæ³å®ã®æéãçµãåŸã«ãæææš©ãŸãã¯ãã®ä»ã®ç©æš©ã®ååŸãããããããšãèªããŠããããã®æ³å¶åºŠã¯ãååŸæå¹ïŒãŸãã¯ååŸçæå¹ïŒãšããŠç¥ãããŠããã
ããã¯ãç©ãå æããè ã«å¯Ÿããèªåçãªå ±é ¬ã§ã¯ãªããããã¯äžå®ã®æ¡ä»¶ã䌎ãå¶åºŠã§ãããããªãã¡ãã©ã®ããã«å æããŠããããæéãäžæã®æç¡ããããŠãã®ç«èšŒãéèŠãšãªãããŸããæ³äœç³»ã«ãã£ãŠã¯ãåæãæ£åœãªæš©åãèæ ®ãããã
管èœåºåã«é¢ããæ³šæïŒ ååŸã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªã財ç£ãèŠä»¶ãæéãäžæäºç±ãããã³æ³çæç¶ãã¯ãåœã«ãã£ãŠãããã«ã¯åäžåœå ã§ãã£ãŠã管èœã«ãã£ãŠç°ãªããæ¬çš¿ã¯äžè¬çãªæ³çã説æãããã®ã§ãããåå¥ã®äºæ¡ã解決ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããé©çšãããæ³ä»€ã®ç¢ºèªã«ä»£ãããã®ã§ããªãã
ååŸæå¹ãšã¯äœãæå³ããã®ã
äžè¬çãªèгç¹ããèšãã°ãååŸæå¹ãšã¯ãäžå®æéç¶ç¶ãããã€æ³åŸã§å®ããããèŠä»¶ãæºããå æãéããŠãæææš©ãŸãã¯ãã®ä»ã®ç©æš©ãååŸããæ æ§ã®äžã€ã§ããããããã£ãŠã以äžã®3ã€ã®æŠå¿µãåºå¥ããŠçè§£ããããšãæçã§ããã
- å æïŒ æ³ãéèŠæ§ãèªãããç©ã«å¯Ÿããäºå®äžã®æ¯é é¢ä¿ã
- æææš©ïŒ æ³äœç³»ã«ãã£ãŠèªããããããã®ç©ã«å¯Ÿããæš©èœãä»äžããæš©å©ã
- ååŸæå¹ïŒ ãã¹ãŠã®åææ¡ä»¶ãç«èšŒãããå Žåã«ãäžå®ã®èŠä»¶ãåããå æç¶æ ãæš©å©ã®ååŸãžãšè»¢æããåŸãå¶åºŠçä»çµã¿ã
ãããã説æã¯ãããããã®åºæã®æ³èŠå®ã䌎ããªãããããŸããŸãªå€§éžæ³ã®äŒçµ±ã«èŠããããã¹ãã€ã³æ°æ³å žã¯æå¹ã«ããæš©å©ååŸãèŠå®ããå æã«ã€ããŠäžå®ã®æ§è³ªãæ±ããŠãããã¡ãã·ã³é£éŠæ°æ³å žããŸããååŸæå¹ïŒç©æ¥µçæå¹ïŒãå æãšçµã³ã€ããå ·äœçãªèŠä»¶ãå®ããŠããããããã¯æçãªååœã®å®äŸã§ãããã¹ãã€ã³èªåå šäœã«å ±éããç»äžçãªèŠåã瀺ããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ æéã®çµéã¯å¿ èŠæ¡ä»¶ã§ããããããã ãã§ã¯ååã§ã¯ãªããæ³çãªåãã¯ãå æãã©ãã»ã©é·ãç¶ãããã ãã§ã¯ãªãããããã©ã®ããã«å§ãŸããã©ã®ããã«è¡äœ¿ãããäžæããããã©ããããããŠäœãç«èšŒã§ãããã§ããã
ãªããã®å¶åºŠãååšããã®ã
äžèŠãããšãååŸæå¹ã¯æææš©ã®ä¿è·ãšççŸããããã«æãããããããªãããã人ç©ãæ£åœãªæš©å©è ã§ãã£ããšããã°ããªãæéã®çµéã«ãã£ãŠä»è ããã®æš©å©ãååŸããããšã容èªããã®ã ãããããã®æžå¿µã¯ãã£ãšãã§ãããããã®å¶åºŠã¯ææè ã®åãªãäžäœçºããåãªãå æã®äžã«æãç«ã£ãŠããããã§ã¯ãªãã
ãã®æ©èœã¯ãé·æã«ããã財ç£çæš©å©é¢ä¿ã®äžç¢ºå®æ§ã«å¯Ÿãã察å¿ãšããŠçè§£ããããšãã§ãããå ¬ç¶ãã€å®å®ããå æç¶æ ãåç¶ããäžæ¹ã§ã圢åŒçãªæš©å©ãšå®éã®ç¶æ ãä¹é¢ãããŸãŸã§ããå Žåããã®ç矩ãç¡æéã«æŸçœ®ããããšã¯ã誰ããã®ç©ãç¶æããè²æž¡ãããããã¯æŽ»çšã§ããã®ããææ¡ããããšãå°é£ã«ããã
ååŸæå¹ã¯ãäºåã«å®ãããã峿 Œãªã«ãŒã«ã®äžã§ãã®ä¹é¢ãåããããšãããã®ã§ãããã¡ãã·ã³åè¡åœæé«åžæ³è£å€æã¯ãããå ·äœçäºæ¡ã«ãããŠãã®å¶åºŠãæ€èšããéããã®æ£åœæ§ãæææš©ã«é¢ããäžç¢ºå®æ§ãç¡æéã«ç¶ãããšãé²ãç¹ã«é¢é£ã¥ããŠããããã ãããã®å³å¯ãªåè¡¡ãã©ãå³ããã¯ãåæ³åã®ç«æ³è ã«å§ããããŠããã
æææš©ãä¿è·ããããšã¯ãåã«æš©åãæ¿èªããããšã«ãšã©ãŸããªããéå»ã®çŽäºã解決ããããã®äºèŠå¯èœãªã«ãŒã«ããŸãå¿ èŠãšãããã®ã§ãããååŸæå¹ãããããæ³çå®å®æ§ã«è³ããã®ã¯ãæç¶ãçä¿éãåè«ã®æ©äŒããããŠæ³å®èŠä»¶ã®éµå®ã䌎ã£ãŠé©çšãããå Žåã«éãããã
éåžžã©ã®ãããªèŠä»¶ãæ±ããããã®ã
æ®éçãªåäžã®èŠä»¶ãªã¹ãã¯ååšããªããããã§ããå€§éžæ³ç³»ã®å€ãã®æ³äœç³»ã¯ãå ±éããŠèŠãããããã€ãã®èŠçŽ ã«çç®ããŠããã
ææã®ææãæã£ãïŒæš©å©è ãšããŠã®ïŒå æ
äžåç£ã«ç©ççã«æåšããããšããç©ã䜿çšããããšã ãã§ã¯è¶³ããªããå æã¯ãæ³ãæ±ããæ æ§ã«ãããŠãéåžžã¯ååŸããããšããæš©å©ã®ä¿æè ãšããŠã®ææãæã£ãŠè¡äœ¿ãããªããã°ãªããªãããã®ç¹ããèªããæš©å©è ãšããŠè¡åããå æè ãšãä»è ã®æš©å©ãèªããŠããå æè ãšãå³»å¥ããåºæºãšãªãã
2ã€ã®ç¶æ³ãèããŠã¿ãããç¡åã§è²žäžãããäœå± ã«å± äœããè ã¯ãååãšããŠä»è ã®èš±è«Ÿã®ååšãèªèããŠãããããã«å¯Ÿããæšå®äžã®æš©å©è ãšããŠå ¬ç¶ããè¡çºãè¡ãè ã¯ãå šãç°ãªãç«å Žã«ããããã£ãšãããã®äŸãç¹å®ã®äºæ¡ã®çµè«ã決å®ã¥ããããã§ã¯ãªããå æã®çºçåå ãšãã®ç«èšŒæ¹æ³ã¯ãåå°åã®æ³èŠç¯ã«å·Šå³ãããã
å ¬ç¶æ§ãç¶ç¶æ§ãããã³å¹³ç©æ§
é ããå æã¯ãç°è°ãå±ãåŸã人ã ããç¶æ³ãé èœãããããæš©å©é¢ä¿ãå®å®ãããæ©èœãæããããšã¯æ¥µããŠå°é£ã§ããããã®ãããå ¬ç¶ãå¹³ç©ããããŠç¶ç¶çãŸãã¯äžæã®ãªãå æãšãã£ãèŠä»¶ãé »ç¹ã«èŠå®ããããããã¯äŸãã°ãã¹ãã€ã³æ°æ³å žç¬¬1941æ¡ãã¡ãã·ã³é£éŠæ°æ³å žç¬¬1151æ¡ã«ãããŠèŠããããšããã§ããã
ãç¶ç¶çããšã¯ãå¿ ãããåžžã«ç©ççã«ååšããŠããããšãæå³ããããã§ã¯ãªããããã¯è²¡ç£ã®æ§è³ªãæ³åŸã«ãã£ãŠèŠå®ãããæ³çãªè©äŸ¡ã§ãããåæ§ã«ããå¹³ç©ãã®æçŸ©ã«ã€ããŠãåæ³åã®èŠå®ã確èªããå¿ èŠãããã
æ³å®æéã®çµé
å æã¯ãæ³åŸã§å®ããããæéã«ããã£ãŠç¶æãããªããã°ãªããªãããã®æéã¯ãåœã財ç£ã®çš®å¥ãé©çšãããæå¹ã®åœ¢æ ããã®ä»ã®äºæ ã«ãã£ãŠç°ãªããããæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯å ·äœçãªå¹Žæ°ãæç€ºããªããããæ³å žã§æ£ãããšãããåäžã®å¹Žæ°ã§ãã£ãŠããå¥ã®æ³å žã«ãããŠã¯å šã劥åœããªãå Žåãããããã§ããã
ããã«ãç¹å®ã®äºç±ã«ãã£ãŠæéã®èšç®ãäžæãããããšããããå æã®åªå€±ãæš©å©ã®è«æ±ããããã¯ä»è ã®æš©å©ã®æ¿èªãªã©ã¯ãåå°åã®æ³ä»€ã«å¿ããŠç°ãªãæ³ç广ãããããå Žåããããåã«å¹Žæ°ãåç®ããåã«ããããªãäºç±ãæ³çã«èæ ®ããããããã©ã®ãããªå¹æãåãŒãããç¹å®ããªããã°ãªããªãã
ååãªç«èšŒ
ååŸæå¹ã䞻匵ããè ã¯ãéåžžããããåºç€ã¥ããäºå®ãç«èšŒããªããã°ãªããªããå ·äœçã«ã¯ãæéãå æã®çºçåå ãè¡ãããè¡çºããã®å¯èŠæ§ãããã³ç¶ç¶æ§ãªã©ãå«ãŸããã
æžé¢ã蚌èšãæ¯æèšé²ããããã¯ä¿å管çè¡çºãªã©ã¯ããããŸã§ã®å æã®çµç·¯ãåæ§æãã蚌æ ãšãªãåŸããããã®ããããçµæãä¿èšŒãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããå ã«åŒçšããã¡ãã·ã³è£å€æã®å€æ±ºããåãªãç©ççææã ãã§ã¯äžååã§ãããå æã®åå ãæ±ºå®çã«ãªãåŸãç¹ã匷調ããŠããã
æ®éååŸæå¹ãšç¹å¥ååŸæå¹
å€ãã®æ³äœç³»ã¯ãæ®éãšç¹å¥ã®åºåãèšããŠãããããããã®åºåãåç§°ã¯æ®éçãªãã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
æ®éååŸæå¹ã¯ãéåžžãåæããã³æ£åœãªæš©åãšçµã³ã€ãããããåãããããèšãã°ãåè ã¯ååŸã®æ£åœæ§ã«é¢ããæ³çã«æçŸ©ã®ãã䞻芳ç確信ãæããåŸè ã¯ãããè£ä»ããæ³çèŠä»¶ãæºãããæ³åŸè¡çºãªã©ãæããåã«ãèªåã®ãã®ã§ãããšæã£ãããšäž»åŒµããã ãã§ã¯è¶³ããªãã
ç¹å¥ååŸæå¹ã¯ãéåžžãããã®èŠçŽ ã®ãããããäžèŠãšãããããã®ä»£ããã«ããé·ãæéãªã©ãç°ãªãæ¡ä»¶ãé©çšããããšãå€ããããã¯ããããªãå æã§ãã£ãŠãæææš©ãžãšè»¢æããããšããæå³ã§ã¯ãªããå æã®æ§è³ªãæéãäžæã®æç¡ã財ç£ã®çš®å¥ãããã³èŠæ±ãããç«èšŒã¯ãäŸç¶ãšããŠæ±ºå®çãªæå³ãæã€ã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ ãæ®éããšãç¹å¥ãã¯å¶åºŠãçè§£ããããã®æçšãªå顿Šå¿µã§ããããããåœããå¥ã®åœãžãšãã®ãŸãŸç§»æ€ã§ããç»äžçãªå ¬åŒã§ã¯ãªããå ·äœçãªèŠä»¶ãšæéã¯ããã®è²¡ç£ãèŠåŸããçŸè¡ã®æ³ä»€ã«ãããŠç¢ºèªãããªããã°ãªããªãã
äœãååŸæå¹ã§ã¯ãªãã®ã
æ¥åžžçšèªã«ãããŠã¯è¿æ¥ããããã€ãã®æŠå¿µãæ··åãããã¡ã§ããããããããç°ãªãçµæãããããã
- ç©ççå æã察象ã®å å®¹ïŒ ç©ã«å¯Ÿããç©ççæ¯é ãŸãã¯äœ¿çšãååŸæå¹ã«è©²åœããªãçç±ïŒ ããåäœã§ã¯ãæ³çã«èŠæ±ãããæ§è³ªãåããå æãæéããã®ä»ã®æ³å®èŠä»¶ãç«èšŒããããšã«ã¯ãªããªãã
- äžæ³å æ ã»äŸµå¥ªã察象ã®å å®¹ïŒ çŸå°æ³ã«åºã¥ãéæ³è¡çºãæ§æãåŸãè¡çºãååŸæå¹ã«è©²åœããªãçç±ïŒ éæ³ãªè¡çºã¯ããããå æãšåŒç§°ãããšããã§èªåçã«æš©å©ãžãšè»¢åããããšã¯ãªãã
- è³è²žåã䜿çšè²žåããŸãã¯é»èªã»å®¹å¿ã察象ã®å å®¹ïŒ ä»è ãšã®é¢ä¿æ§ã蚱諟ã«åºã¥ã䜿çšãååŸæå¹ã«è©²åœããªãçç±ïŒ æ³åŸã§èªãããç«èšŒãããæ¹æ³ã«ãã£ãŠãã®ç¶æ³ãå€åããªãéããéåžžã¯ä»è ã®æš©å©ãèªããŠããããšãæå³ããã
- æ¶æ» æå¹ã察象ã®å å®¹ïŒ äžå®ã®èŠåã«åºã¥ã蚎暩ãåµåã®åªå€±ãŸãã¯æ¶æ» ãååŸæå¹ã«è©²åœããªãçç±ïŒ ååŸæå¹ã¯ç©æš©ã®ååŸãæ±ããã®ã§ãããäž¡è ã¯å矩ã§ã¯ãªãã
äžæ žçãªçžéã¯ããã®ç©ãšç©ççã«æ¥è§ŠããŠããããšãšãæå¹ååŸã«å¿ èŠãªæ³çæ§è³ªãåããŠå æããŠããããšã®éã«ååšããããã®äž¡è ãæ··åããããšã¯ãåã«ç«ã¡å ¥ããçãŸããåŸ ã¡ããããã°æš©å©ãåŸããããšãã誀ã£ãèªèãå©é·ããããšã«ãªãã
æš©å©ã®ååŸãç«èšŒã倿±ºã»å®£èšã®ååŸãããã³ç»èš
å®éã®äºæ¡ã«ãããŠã¯ãæ··åããŠã¯ãªããªãå°ãªããšã4ã€ã®å±é¢ãååšããã
- æš©å©ã®ååŸïŒ æ³åŸäžãæš©å©ãååŸããããšã¿ãªãããæç¹ããã³èŠä»¶ã
- ç«èšŒïŒ ãããã®èŠä»¶ãæ§æããäºå®ã®èšŒæã
- 確èªå®£èšïŒ äºããããå ŽåããŸãã¯æ³åŸãèŠæ±ããå Žåã«ããã®ç¶æ³ãèªããè£å€æã®æ±ºå®ãŸãã¯ç®¡èœæ©é¢ã®ä»çµã¿ã
- ç»èšïŒ ç»èšç°¿ãžã®æš©å©ã®èšé²ããªãã³ã«ãã®å ¬ç€ºå¹æãŸãã¯ç¬¬äžè ã«å¯Ÿããä¿è·ã
ãããåå±é¢ã®çžäºé¢ä¿ã¯ãã©ãã§ãåäžã§ãããšã¯éããªããéå®çãªäžäŸãšããŠãã¡ãã·ã³é£éŠæ°æ³å žç¬¬1156æ¡ããã³ç¬¬1157æ¡ã¯ãæ³å®ã®æéããã³èŠä»¶ãæºãããŠå æããè ãæå¹ã®å®æå®£èšãæ±ãã蚎èšãæèµ·ãããã®å€æ±ºãç»èšç°¿ã«èšèŒããããšãæ³å®ããŠããããã®æç¶ãã®æµãã¯ãä»åœããã¡ãã·ã³åœå ã«ååšãããã¹ãŠã®æ³å¶åºŠã«å¯ŸããŠèªåçã«åœãŠã¯ããããšã¯ã§ããªãã
éèŠãã€ã³ãïŒ å®è³ªçã«äžå®ã®èŠä»¶ãæºããããšãããããç«èšŒããããšãå ¬çãªç¢ºèªãåŸãããšããããŠç»èšäžã®å¹æãåŸãããšã¯ãçžäºã«é¢é£ããŠã¯ãããã®ã®ãããããç°ãªãåé¡ã§ããã
å ·äœçãªäºæ¡ã«æŠå¿µãé©çšããåã«
責任ããæ€èšã¯ãç®¡èœæ³åããã³çŸè¡æ³ä»€ãç¹å®ããããšããå§ãŸãããã®äžã§ã䞻匵ããããšããæš©å©ã®å 容ããã®è²¡ç£ãååŸæå¹ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªãåŸããåŠããå æã®éå§åå ããããŠäžæäºç±ãäºãã®æç¡ã粟æ»ããªããã°ãªããªãã
ããããæ éãã¯åãªã圢åŒäž»çŸ©ã§ã¯ãªããè²¡ç£æš©ã®äºèŠå¯èœæ§ã¯ãææ§ãªã¹ããŒã¬ã³ã«ãã£ãŠèª°ãæš©å©ã倱ã£ããååŸãããããªãããšã«ããã£ãŠãããååŸæå¹ã¯ãé·å¹Žã®äžç¢ºå®æ§ããå ¬çãªã«ãŒã«ãååãªèšŒæ ããããŠåœäºè ãžã®æç¶ãçä¿éã«åºã¥ãã解決çãžãšçœ®ãæããå Žåã«ãæ£åœãªæ©èœãæããããããã®æ¡ä»¶ãæ¬ ããªãã°ãåãªãæŠã®äžã§ã®æéã®çµéãæææš©ãçã¿åºãããšã¯æ±ºããŠãªãã
å ±æ